AI for coding makes sense. AI for art is a different story.
retained text
If you approach these two things in the same way, I honestly think it shows a real lack of artistic sensitivity. What makes you approach asset creation and programming as if they were the same thing? Code, and engineering in general, is a means of solving problems. In game development, those problems are usually the game mechanics envisioned by the game designer or design team. For example, I want a grappling hook mechanic in my game. That means I need the player to be able to grab surfaces, move through space, maintain momentum etc.. So why since AI became a thing, everyone suddenly seems so concerned with the process used to solve these problems? I don't remember people being nearly as worked up about whether someone used Blueprints, copied code from Stack Overflow, or relied on an existing library. What matters is the technical result: Does it work? Is it reliable? Is it performant? Does it meet the game design requirements? That's what programming is about: starting with a problem and finding a solution. AI naturally fits into that process, just like the internet did when we used it to find existing code, or just like libraries have always done. Art, on the other hand, isn't a problem to be solved, nor is it about reaching some optimal result. An artist expresses something. A colour might be chosen because it evokes a memory. A musical composition might be deliberately imperfect to create a sense of unease. And most importantly, these choices aren't interchangeable. Behind every artistic decision, there can be an intention, a personal experience, a cultural reference, an emotion, or even a happy accident. What have you actually expressed if an AI generated an image for you? The creative process is part of the artwork itself. And just to be clear: I'm not denying that code can be an art form. Programmers can find aesthetic satisfaction in writing code. But that doesn't change the nature of the problem they're trying to solve. Being personally attached to an activity doesn't change its fundamental purpose. And on top of all that, there's the ethical aspect: code is much easier to protect and control than an artistic work. All it takes is for your artwork to be photographed and uploaded to the internet, and there's a good chance it will end up being reproduced by an LLM. When it comes to code, LLMs are trained on publicly available code: open-source repositories, Stack Overflow, publicly accessible online courses, and so on. An artist can't simply exist in the shadows, even if they wanted to. Their work needs to be visible for them to exist professionally, and that visibility can be exploited without their consent.
document fetched 2026-11-03 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xme7cq/ai_for_coding_makes_sense_ai_for_art_is_a