← sources

Etsy approved a return despite flaws being visible in photos. Is this normal?

source: reddit (reddit:EtsySellers)published 2026-10-24 00:11ingested 2026-10-24 10:57

retained text

I sell vintage collectibles and have a no-returns policy.  
A buyer requested a return because they hadn’t noticed a flaw that was visible in my original listing photos. They acknowledged overlooking it but argued that I should have explicitly mentioned it in the written description.  
Etsy approved the return despite my objections.  
I’ve repeatedly asked whether Etsy reviewed my photographs and why the item was considered not as described. None of my questions have been answered.  
Instead, Etsy instructed the buyer to ship the item back and is now telling me to resolve the case.  
**My question:** If a flaw is visible in listing photos but not specifically mentioned in the description, is that enough for Etsy to approve a return?  
Has anyone successfully challenged a decision like this or gotten Etsy to actually address their evidence?

document fetched 2026-10-24 10:28 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1xdub25/etsy_approved_a_return_despite_flaws_being