Cancelled a medium-risk order for fraud, customer reordered with the SAME card minutes later and it came back low risk + Shopify Protect active.
retained text
Small leather brand here, first time dealing with this. Heres the run down: **Order 1:** \~$250 international order (Mexico) through Managed Markets, paid with Amex via Shop Pay. Shopify flagged it as **medium risk** with two indicators: * Credit card related to other fraudulent orders * Customer location does not match payment method Shopify Protect showed **Not eligible**, so I cancelled it as fraudulent and refunded. **Order 2:** Within minutes of emailing the "customer" and cancelling, the same customer reordered. Same email, same shipping address, **same Amex card**, but a different product (different size and variation) at the same price. This time: * Risk: **Low** * Shopify Protect: **Active** (covered if I ship with tracking by the deadline) My questions: 1. Has anyone seen the risk score flip like this on the same card within minutes? 2. Is an instant reorder after a fraud cancellation a red flag, or just a real customer who wants the product? 3. Has anyone actually had Shopify Protect pay out on a fraud chargeback? Was it smooth? Leaning toward not shipping because it could be a scammer/competition (I have no clue), but since Protect is active, I'll get paid for it nevertheless. Curious what others would do.
document fetched 2026-10-29 00:31 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/shopify/comments/1xhdps2/cancelled_a_mediumrisk_order_for_fraud_customer