← sources

Traced one ₹300 food-delivery order rupee by rupee: 18 % GST comes off the rider's fee (9(5) local delivery), and the government earns 3.4× what the platform does. Is my reading right?

source: reddit (reddit:IndiaTax)published 2026-09-19 13:48ingested 2026-09-20 02:39

retained text

I'm building a small delivery dispatch for cafés in Kullu (solo; a handful of cafés, not a Swiggy). While working out the GST posture with our CA I hit something that shocked me, and I'd like this sub to check both my arithmetic and my reading of the law.

**The part that shocked me**

Since 22 Sept 2025, *local delivery services* supplied through an e-commerce operator by an unregistered person sit under section 9(5): the platform pays the 18 %, in cash, with no ITC against it. Every delivery rider is unregistered. So on a ₹60 delivery fee shown inclusive to the guest, ₹9.15 is GST and the rider gets ₹50.85. The platform earns nothing on the ride, so the 18 % has to come out of either the guest or the rider — there is nobody else in that line.

**One ₹300 order, rupee by rupee**

Assumptions: menu ₹300 excl. GST · delivery ₹60 shown inclusive · platform fee ₹10 + 18 % · payment gateway 2 % + 18 % GST on its fee · one checkout on the café's gateway · café on the 5 % no-ITC restaurant rate.

What the guest pays:

|line|base|GST|guest pays|
|:-|:-|:-|:-|
|Food|300.00|5 % = 15.00|315.00|
|Delivery|50.85|18 % = 9.15|60.00|
|Platform fee|10.00|18 % = 1.80|11.80|
|**Total**|360.85|**25.95**|**386.80**|

Where it ends up:

|who|gets|how|
|:-|:-|:-|
|Café|₹292.92|₹300 − ₹7.08 gateway cost on its own money|
|Rider|₹50.85|₹60 − ₹9.15|
|Government|₹27.34|15.00 food + 9.15 delivery + 1.80 fee + 1.39 GST on the gateway fee|
|Payment gateway|₹7.74|2 % of the whole ₹386.80|
|Platform|₹7.95|₹10 fee − ₹2.05 gateway cost on the ₹86.80 it passes through|

Adds up to ₹386.80. The government earns 3.4× what the platform does on the order, and the rider's ₹9.15 alone is more than the platform's whole take.

**Tax on tax on tax**

The gateway charges 2 % on the GST-inclusive total, so ₹0.55 of its fee is 2 % of the ₹25.95 of GST, and then 18 % GST applies on that ₹0.55 (₹0.10). Small, but the ₹1.39 GST on the gateway fee is dead money for a café on the 5 % rate — it can't claim it back.

**What I'd like checked**

1. Is 9(5) on local delivery correctly applied when the platform does *not* collect the money? (The café's gateway collects; the café passes the delivery + fee amounts through to us on a statement.)
2. If we're the ECO for the delivery leg, does that make us the ECO for the restaurant food as well — i.e. the 5 % on food becomes ours to remit and the café reports those orders as "supplies through ECO, tax paid by operator"? Our CA leans yes; I'd like to hear where the line actually is.
3. Is there any recognised structure that stops the café eating the ₹1.39 GST on the gateway fee, given the no-ITC restaurant rate?

No links, nothing to sell. If the arithmetic is wrong I'd genuinely like to know — it changes what we build.

document fetched 2026-09-20 00:40 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndiaTax/comments/1wkmqgw/traced_one_300_fooddelivery_order_rupee_by_rupee