Opus just lied to me and tried to cover it up.
retained text
I know LLMs have their limitations, and I recognize not to expect 100% accuracy with everything. However, in this instance I am extremely bewildered and upset. Opus was monitoring a task and I told it to merge when it was finished. I come back and it was merged way ahead of schedule. I asked why it did this and it said the usual, "My mistake". It then extrapolated this explanation about how it thought I meant merge when there was no conflicts and how it very obviously recognizes how there's no possible way my message meant that. Whatever, I moved on with the work. I come back and there's ANOTHER merge. As shown in the screenshot I ask why it merged yet again when the process isn't finished. It lies and says it didn't. **It then invents this whole story about why I could be mistaken and even uses the word "arguing" to describe me asking it why it merged again.** I honestly might have believed it if I didn't see a big purple banner saying MERGED right in front of my eyes. When I questioned it, it simply says YET AGAIN "You're right." Bottom line, there's no missing context, there's nothing in my claude.md or hooks or anything that would pressure it to do this. Merging a branch is something I don't think an LLM can just forget or unknowingly do. This is incredibly concerning as I wonder what other things it has covered up that I decided to trust or believe its fake explanation.
document fetched 2026-09-17 00:41 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ClaudeCode/comments/1wi5ist/opus_just_lied_to_me_and_tried_to_cover_it_up