← sources

60% win rate and still losing, so I went to widen the target. The trade list said that would make it worse.

source: reddit (reddit:algotrading)published 2026-11-18 10:20ingested 2026-11-19 02:40

retained text

I had a 1m NQ setup that won 60.2% of its trades over 535 trades across three years and still finished net negative. Average win $522, average loss $806, profit factor 0.98, net **-$3,675**.

The obvious fix, and the one I reached for first, is widen the target. 1:1 isnt working so go 1:2 and let the winners pay for the losers. On paper thats free at a 60% hit rate, because **you only need 34% to break even at 1:2.**

Then I read the trade list instead of the summary line. **322 of the 535 winners closed in single digit candles.** Most of the wins arent trades that ran, theyre trades that touched the target almost straight away and were done.

That changes what widening actually does. Im not handing a winner more room, Im taking 322 trades that already closed and asking price to travel twice as far from the same entry, with the stop sitting exactly where it always was. A big share of those turn into round trips back to the stop, and the win rate the whole plan depends on is the thing that pays for it.

The other half of it is where the entry sits. Stop and target were both 2x ATR, so on paper its 1:1. But the entry is the confirmation close back above the level while the stop is measured off the level itself, so by the time Im filled the stop is already further away than the target. **Thats how a 1:1 design comes out 0.65:1 realized**, $522 against $806.

Its like timing a bus from when it leaves the depot and then getting on three stops later. The schedule is fine, Im just not where I measured from.

So the thing that looks like a target problem is a geometry problem, and widening the target without moving the entry pays more for the same bad fill.

Im running the same 535 trade window at 1:2 and 1:2.5, same everything else, and Ill post it whichever way it falls.

document fetched 2026-11-19 00:45 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/algotrading/comments/1xzbs65/60_win_rate_and_still_losing_so_i_went_to_widen