← sources

My Etsy shop is being destroyed

source: reddit (reddit:EtsySellers)published 2026-10-30 22:04ingested 2026-10-31 02:37

retained text

Hi everyone. I’m completely desperate and watching the shop I’ve built for 2 years literally slip through my fingers. I sell PDF sewing patterns. Over the last two years, I’ve had over 4,000 sales, 250+ great reviews, and maintained Star Seller status. I always reply to messages within 5 minutes and even make custom patterns to fit clients' measurements for free.

This month, everything turned into a nightmare. I started getting 1-star reviews every 1-2 days on my proven bestsellers—listings I haven’t changed at all.

The biggest red flags: not a single one of these buyers responds to my messages. Recently, one 1-star review literally said, "I can't find the item in the mail." It's a digital PDF download! I reported it under the policy "Review is about Etsy or a third party," but Support refused to remove it, claiming it is "objective." I opened a new ticket, and they just closed it without a single word. No automated reply, nothing. I've never seen them close a ticket without even a standard macro.

My rating for the last 3 months has dropped to 4.6, I’ve fallen below service standards, and it keeps getting worse. It feels like a coordinated bot attack from a competitor. Has anyone experienced this? How do I get past the automated support system to reach a real human in Trust & Safety before my shop is ruined?

document fetched 2026-10-31 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1xjstdr/my_etsy_shop_is_being_destroyed