← sources

What exactly is the FEMA violation in the recent ED raid on Instadapp/Fluid DeFi? Can someone familiar with FEMA and crypto regulations explain?

source: reddit (reddit:IndiaTax)published 2026-10-31 05:20ingested 2026-11-01 02:41

retained text

On 27 October 2026, the Enforcement Directorate conducted searches involving Instadapp/Fluid, a DeFi protocol operating on the Ethereum blockchain, over alleged FEMA violations.

According to the ED, although the platform was presented as being operated by a US-registered company (Instadapp Labs LLC, Delaware), the company was allegedly just a paper entity, with the founder and development team operating from India.

The ED further alleged that revenue generated through the DeFi protocol was routed through entities in the British Virgin Islands, Singapore and the UAE without complying with FEMA provisions.

**My question is: What exactly makes these activities a FEMA violation?**

I have a few doubts:

1. **How does FEMA define cross-border transactions involving cryptocurrency?** As far as I understand, FEMA does not explicitly define cryptocurrency as foreign exchange or foreign securities. Crypto exists on a decentralised blockchain, and transferring tokens between wallets does not necessarily involve moving fiat currency between countries. How is the jurisdiction or cross-border nature of such a transaction legally determined?
2. **What is illegal about an Indian founder operating a US-registered company?** Many Indian entrepreneurs operate international businesses through foreign entities. Does the fact that the founder and development team operate from India automatically create a FEMA violation? Or would the violation arise from specific overseas investment, ownership, control or reporting requirements?
3. **What is wrong with routing business revenue through foreign companies?** If a DeFi protocol earns revenue in cryptocurrency, holds it in wallets, converts it into fiat through overseas exchanges and subsequently remits money to India through authorised banking channels, which exact FEMA provision is violated?
4. **What if the inward remittances were received under a legitimate purpose code?** The ED alleges that funds were brought into India as bogus software development and consultancy fees. But if genuine services were actually provided by Indian entities, supported by contracts, invoices and appropriate banking documentation, would those inward remittances be FEMA-compliant? Does the use of cryptocurrency before conversion into fiat change the legal position?
5. **Does holding cryptocurrency in a wallet controlled by an Indian resident amount to holding foreign assets abroad under Section 4 of FEMA?** Given that cryptocurrency exists on a decentralised blockchain rather than in a particular country, how is its geographical location determined for FEMA purposes?

I understand that tax evasion, sham entities, undisclosed overseas investments and misrepresentation of transactions are separate potential issues.

However, **I want to understand the specific FEMA violations rather than assume that using cryptocurrency or operating through foreign companies is inherently illegal.**

Can someone knowledgeable about FEMA, RBI regulations or international taxation explain which provisions could apply here, particularly Sections 3, 4, 6 and 8 of FEMA and the Overseas Investment Rules?

I would especially appreciate references to the actual statutory provisions, RBI regulations or relevant judicial decisions.

https://preview.redd.it/qtajkojamqyh1.png?width=357&format=png&auto=webp&s=d471d2cd158062334eef807c65f2ea4a172f311a

document fetched 2026-11-01 00:41 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/IndiaTax/comments/1xk1tp3/what_exactly_is_the_fema_violation_in_the_recent