Wishlists are not sales
retained text
I know everyone already knows how important wishlists can be, but given the constant inundation of wishlist posts in r/gamedev, I'd like to remind everyone that wishlists correlate well with sales but they are not sales. Your game can plausibly convert anywhere from 0.05x to 3x of wishlists as Week 1 sales. These are outliers no doubt, but if you are making a great game and are terrible at marketing there is a realistic scenario where you sell 2x your wishlists in Week 1 (while the median is like 0.1x-0.15x). How do I know? Well, I was looking at our last game's stats 1 year after launch, and it (kind of) happened to us! About a year ago, we launched Q-UP, a multiplayer esports satire autobattler incremental game (yeah, I am bad at marketing). We went into launch with a respectable **14.5k wishlists.** That's not bad for a solo project but for a four-person team working for a year it wouldn't have made back our investment. People (including me) were panicking a bit after plugging wishlist numbers into calculators. But at some point we realized wishlists were just a correlative measure, that our four-person team was much better at making games than at marketing them, and that the standard Games Industry Marketing Blog Wishlist To Sales Calculators were therefore basically garbage data for us. I looked at our game, saw the viral potential + quality + uniqueness, and was very confident we were going to beat the 0.1x Wishlist-W1-Sales-Ratio by a lot. W1 sales of Q-UP ended up being **14,425 copies** for almost exactly a **1x Wishlist-W1-Sales-Ratio**. That's about 10 times what a marketing sales calculator told us we should earn. But I don't think it was really a surprise for us. We are not good at marketing and we were able to look critically at our game and really truly believe it was competitive in quality and it was bringing something new to Steam. We felt very confident that, in our case, wishlists were going to be a weak predictor. This isn't an insane, set-up-for-life amount of sales for a four-person team, just a keep-the-company-alive amount of sales. But I wanted to give a concrete example to back up my argument: there are other viable paths to making a successful game. Having 100k wishlists and converting at the median amount is an absolutely great way to sell games, but it's not the only way. If you are good at looking at your game critically and you can genuinely say the quality of your game is extremely high compared to other commercial steam games then you will probably outperform your wishlists. If you are also really bad at marketing on top of that then you will probably outperform your wishlists. On the other hand, if you're great at marketing or your game is great looking but not super fun then you will probably underperform your wishlists. All this to say, **there is still a place in this industry for people who are fully focused on making games and are not very good at self-promotion.** Sometimes it can feel like that opportunity has come and gone, and I don't mean to give anyone who is truly struggling false hope. But the opportunity is still there. Wishlists are still a great stat to look at, and a very good correlation! But in the end, that's all they are: a correlation.
document fetched 2026-10-24 10:28 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xdqts9/wishlists_are_not_sales