← sources

4x4TB RAID6 with enterprise Seagate Exos drives in a bedroom NAS - bad idea?

source: reddit (reddit:homelab)published 2026-10-18 21:34ingested 2026-10-19 02:41

retained text

Hi everyone,

Planning my first proper NAS and considering enterprise drives instead of consumer NAS drives. Looking for real experience, not reviews.

Drive: Seagate Exos 7E8, model ST4000NM000A
- 4 TB, 3.5", SATA 6 Gb/s, native 512n sectors
- 7200 RPM, 256 MB cache
- CMR (not SMR)
- enterprise/datacenter line
- 5-year warranty, 550 TB/year rated workload


Planned setup:
- 4 x 4 TB in RAID6 (8 TB usable out of 16 TB raw)
- NAS: [model]
- Location: bedroom, a few metres from the bed
- Use: [photo/doc backup, media server, etc.]
- Noise sensitivity: high, I sleep next to it

Questions:

1) Noise: 4 x 7200 RPM drives in one box — how bad is it in a room where you
   sleep? Is it airflow/platter noise or vibration coupling into the furniture?
   Did rubber grommets or suspension mounts actually help?

2) Night activity: scheduled scrubs, backups, array rebuilds. Do they wake you
   up? Can you confine them to daytime hours without hurting RAID6 integrity?

3) Power: 4 enterprise drives plus the NAS — what's the yearly cost difference
   vs 4 x 5400 RPM drives? Is spin-down worth it, or does it just stress drives?

4) RAID6 on 4 drives: does it make sense? Usable capacity is identical to
   RAID10 (8 TB) but with a bigger write penalty and much slower rebuilds.
   Would you pick RAID6 again at 4 drives, or go RAID10?

5) Compatibility: any issues with your NAS vendor's official compatibility list?
   Do spin-down, SMART and alerts work normally on enterprise drives?

6) Alternatives: at the same price, WD Red Plus, IronWolf or Toshiba N300?
 And is 4 TB still sensible, or is €/TB too poor at that size?

Thanks!

document fetched 2026-10-19 00:32 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/homelab/comments/1x9f348/4x4tb_raid6_with_enterprise_seagate_exos_drives