Mobile Game: Game design hint system dilemma
retained text
Hi everyone! I'm producing a mobile single-player card puzzle game (it is my first game ever!), and I'm facing a game design dilemma regarding the Hint System. Players must arrange cards across several columns,. Cards can be rearranged freely, but sometimes the board becomes impossible to solve through card movements alone. Players can use limited resources (special abilities) to unblock the board. I'm implementing a solver that checks whether a valid card arrangement exists, and I'd like to monetize the Hint System through rewarded ads by suggesting that cards movements/combination. **Dilemma:** Initially, I thought the Hint button should only offer an ad only if a solution exists. Otherwise, it would tell the player that no valid moves are available. However, I realized this creates a form of unintended cheating. Part of the puzzle is figuring out whether a valid arrangement still exists or whether it's time to "sacrifice" a limited resource. If the Hint button tells players for free that no solution exists, it essentially removes that decision-making process. As of now, I decided to offer the ad-hint regardless. I am afraid that some players might feel disappointed after watching an ad only to be told to use a resource, rather than receiving an actual card solution. On the other hand, providing this information for free would undermine an important part of the puzzle. May I ask your opinion on this? What would you do? I need a fresh brainstorming. Thanks for any feedback!
document fetched 2026-11-04 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xmszun/mobile_game_game_design_hint_system_dilemma