Don’t ask people to give up a fundamental right within seven days
retained text
[Donate Now](https://static.internetfreedom.in/donate) # tl;dr At 9:54 PM on 29 October 2026, IFF, [SFLC.in](http://SFLC.in) and the operator of the X account u/geoblockedindia received a "legal notice" said to be issued purportedly on behalf of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS). It asks us to stop opposing the Government's blocking directions, stop documenting restricted content, and stop posting details of geo-blocked posts. It wants this confirmed in writing within seven days. We do not know whether the RSS authorised it. Replies go to a free Proton Mail address, the "office" is a residential flat in outer Delhi, and the signatory has no name. Whoever wrote it, the notice is a fine teaching aid. Below are seven lessons on how not to draft one, with some help from the Supreme Court. We have replied to say the notice is legally deficient, and we will not be confirming compliance. Our work continues. # Background The email reached our legal team at 9:54 PM on Thursday, 29 October 2026. It was also addressed to [SFLC.in](http://SFLC.in) and to the operator of the u/geoblockedindia account. The covering note said the attachment was a legal notice "issued on behalf of Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh" and asked us to acknowledge receipt. The notice runs to two pages. It is printed on a letterhead bearing the RSS's name and signed by an "Authorised Signatory" who is never named. So it seems plausible that this is a silly prank, or has been issued by someone who is not even from the RSS. It makes three complaints: 1. That IFF has "continuously opposed" the Government's directions to platforms under the IT Act, including, it says, MeitY's October 2026 advisories to Meta on content about protests and police action. 2. That SFLC.in's Free Speech Tracker lists content removals and account restrictions, and so "effectively guides people" to the content through VPNs. 3. That u/geoblockedindia posted details, on 24 October 2026, of a government order under which Reddit geo-blocked 26 posts in India, mostly about the India-China border, Galwan Valley and maps of Arunachal Pradesh. It adds that Reddit filed the order with the Lumen Database, and that IFF issued a statement calling the order unlawful and secretive. It then calls on all three of us to stop, to confirm within seven days that we will, and warns of "appropriate legal action" under "the applicable provisions of law" if we don't. We have redacted the phone number and street address from the copy we are publishing, and we are not naming the advocate mentioned in the covering email. If someone has borrowed other people's names to send this, those details may belong to people who had nothing to do with it. # Analysis No statute prescribes the form of a legal notice sent by one private party to another, however, it must tell the recipient who is complaining, about what, under which law, and what happens next. We can tell this “legal notice” is an excellent teaching aid and here are seven lessons from it. 1. Say who you are: The notice names no advocate and gives no enrollment number. It is signed by an “Authorised Signatory” with no name. Replies go to a free Proton Mail ID, and the “office” is a residential flat in outer Delhi. A notice that can’t tell you who sent it is less a legal document than a weather event. 2. Have a grievance of your own: It never says how its client is harmed when we criticise a MeitY advisory. It complains on behalf of the Government’s blocking orders. The Union has no shortage of lawyers, and it hasn’t asked for volunteers. 3. Name the law: It threatens “appropriate legal action” under “the applicable provisions of law” and doesn’t cite a single section of any statute. A threat with no law, is literally an empty threat. 4. Don’t ask people to give up a fundamental right within seven days: The first demand is that we stop “publicly opposing” government directions. In Shreya Singhal (2015), the Supreme Court held that discussion and advocacy of a cause, however unpopular, sit at the heart of Article 19(1)(a). Opposing an order is how its legality gets tested. That is the Constitution working as intended. 5. Check whether the courts asked for the thing you want stopped” In Anuradha Bhasin (2020), the Supreme Court held that orders restricting fundamental rights must be made available so people can challenge them. The Reddit order is on the public Lumen Database because Reddit put it there. Reading a public database and saying what’s in it has a name. It’s called research. 6. Show us the spark and the powder keg: The notice says our work weakens national security measures, but it gives no instance, date or harm. In S. Rangarajan (1989), the Supreme Court held that the danger feared from speech can’t be remote, conjectural or far-fetched. It has to be like a spark in a powder keg. A post about a Lumen filing is not a spark. 7. Read it once more before you press send: The paragraphs run 1, then an empty 2 and 3, then 4. A PIN code wanders into the facts. The account it targets is on “Twitter”. # Action We will not be confirming compliance, in seven days or at all. We have replied to the notice, and our reply is attached to this post. It reads: Dear Sir, We acknowledge receipt of your email dated 29th October 2026, attaching a notice purportedly issued on behalf of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh. The notice is legally deficient because it makes no material allegation against the Internet Freedom Foundation and cites no illegality or provision of law that our work is said to violate. Public criticism of government directions and the documentation of orders that restrict online speech are exercises of the freedom of speech and expression guaranteed by Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution of India. The notice discloses no cause of action against us. We will therefore respectfully continue to advance constitutional rights, as we have done before, and decline to give the confirmation your notice seeks. Yours faithfully, Apar Gupta We stand with [SFLC.in](http://SFLC.in) and with the operator of u/geoblockedindia. Our work goes on. We will keep offering pro-bono legal aid against blocking orders while haters will keep hating. Our offer of pro bono legal support to the moderators, authors and users affected by the Reddit geo-blocking order still stands. If your post or account has been blocked in India, write to us at [legal@internetfreedom.in](mailto:legal@internetfreedom.in). If you would like to help us keep going, become an IFF member. # Important documents 1. Legal notice dated 29 October 2026, with phone number and street address redacted [(link)](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1kajCb_NGwvx5VfjKoLltNPCC3K5hIC_Q/view?usp=sharing&ref=static.internetfreedom.in) 2. IFF's reply to the notice [(link)](https://drive.google.com/file/d/1lw-cUl2aomElmGpBRmOMPhAGLlFAI3C1/view?usp=sharing&ref=static.internetfreedom.in) 3. IFF's statement of 25 October 2026 on the geo-blocking of 26 Reddit posts [(link)](https://x.com/internetfreedom/status/2114309920929808797?a=QBngAKyFVUQMZFbAk1U&s=20&ref=static.internetfreedom.in) 4. IFF's statement on MeitY's October 2026 advisories to Meta [(link)](https://x.com/internetfreedom/status/2112057367353610546?a=NYSOnSxtd5qPiYsKDnA&s=20&ref=static.internetfreedom.in) 5. SFLC.in's Free Speech Tracker [(link)](https://freespeech.sflc.in/?ref=static.internetfreedom.in) [Donate Now](https://static.internetfreedom.in/donate)
document fetched 2026-10-31 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/india/comments/1xj8fo8/dont_ask_people_to_give_up_a_fundamental_right