This shipping notification change is awful
retained text
Last week Etsy changed their system so that it only notifies the buyer an item is shipped when the package is scanned into the tracking system, instead of sending the notification as soon as a label is printed. Already in the few days since that change I’ve gotten two angry messages from buyers accusing me of not shipping their packages by the deadline. I’ve literally never gotten any messages like this across my ~450 sales, even when there were significant shipping delays, because they could see the packages had been marked as shipped and it was out of my hands. The USPS tracking system has gotten increasingly unreliable lately, and none of the packages I shipped on Tuesday were scanned into the system at all. They eventually started showing up days later, already in transit and on their way to the destination, but it means some of the items shipped on Tuesday didn’t send the buyer a shipping notification until Saturday. I get why they’re doing this, it seems like lots of online marketplaces have issues with sellers who print labels and then don’t actually ship for days. But punishing the people who do things right is never the solution. The real solution here is blindingly obvious, do what eBay does. Change the phrasing to say something like “a label has been created” when you send the initial email, then you can send another when the item actually gets scanned into the system. That wouldn’t have necessarily helped much in situations like mine where tracking doesn’t get updated, but at least I wouldn’t have angry buyers accusing me of not shipping their items. I just hope they revert this change before the holidays, it’s going to be chaos and I can’t imagine USPS’s failing tracking system will be able to handle it, how could they have not realized how badly this change would backfire? Edit: I’m getting a lot of off-topic replies that don’t really acknowledge the issue, so to reiterate: according to the angry buyers in question, Etsy is not sending out any kind of notification to the buyer until the package is scanned, therefore it now looks like I’m not meeting my shipping deadlines. If they could see that the order was fulfilled as promised there wouldn’t be an issue, but they said that it was showing no progress on the order and that’s why they contacted me. I don’t care about buyers being mad that a label had been created and the item wasn’t shipped until days later, that’s not the issue here and I’ve never once had a complaint about delayed tracking information. Also “go to the post office” is unhelpful and useless advice.
document fetched 2026-10-18 00:24 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1x8gepn/this_shipping_notification_change_is_awful