I emailed 410 indie content creators about my Steam demo. Here is the reply funnel (URL to Sankey inside).
retained text
I am the solo dev of A Dark Cave, a dark story-driven minimalist incremental village builder. I am participating in Steam Next Fest from 19-26 Oct 2026, and my game will launch on 27 Oct 2026. So I thought contacting some content creators might be helpful. Over the last few weeks, I sent emails to indie content creators who are active on YouTube / Twitch / TikTok / Instagram. As I like data, I tracked every recipient and classified the outcome. **Funnel** [**(Sankey URL)**](https://imgur.com/a2pB8Z9)**:** * **410 tip emails sent** * **391 no reply** * **19 replied** * **4 declined / not interested** * **4 soft interest (did not lead anywhere yet)** * **5 paid/sponsored offers** * **3 promised future coverage** * **3 made or published content** That is a **\~4.6% reply rate**, and \~1% of emails turned into actual content. I tried to do some A/B testing, but as the general amount of answers was so low, I was not able to draw any conclusions. I don't know if this is any helpful at all to anyone, but maybe at least mildly interesting. From the chats I had with content creators, I learned only what I already knew: Marketing a game with minimalistic visuals is really hard on Social Media. So I guess this could be one of the reasons the resonance was so low. This is the link to A Dark Cave on Steam: [https://store.steampowered.com/app/4882240/A\_Dark\_Cave/](https://store.steampowered.com/app/4882240/A_Dark_Cave/) edit: I got a lot of valuable feedback on both my game and its marketing from this thread, even though that wasn't my original intention. Thanks so much to everyone who took the time to respond!
document fetched 2026-09-26 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1wpvk29/i_emailed_410_indie_content_creators_about_my