← sources

Old man yells at cloud (takes on AI)

source: reddit (reddit:gamedev)published 2026-10-30 08:19ingested 2026-10-31 02:37

retained text

If a person spent 30 minutes on the top posts of the main gamedev subreddits, they could not be blamed for coming out of that experience quite sad, anxious, and completely confused.

There is a lot (and rightfully so) discourse around AI, but I can't help but feel that we are harming each other in the process, and that is bad. 

I am adding another drop of water in the ocean with this post... I'm not original, but I want to try and bring some optimism. Or more likely I'll piss everyone off, who knows. 

So here are my takes, in no particular order:

* **Capitalism has ALWAYS put human flourishing and societal wellbeing BEHIND the goal of maximizing profit and accumulating capital.** 
   * The thing about "I wish AI would do my laundries, and not my creative work..." is very true, but this has always been true. New technology never alleviates our workload, it just increases it. AI is part of this process.
   * I only bring this up because I sincerely get the feeling that people are only now finally waking up to the fact that we are exploited... guys, its been like this for a long time... 
   * This is not to say we shouldn't push back on the objective downsides of AI, of which there are plenty - BUT, this is mainly said so we can calibrate the seeming anger we are throwing at each other... yes my friends, the world needs a lot of change. But we won't get there by shitting on GAME DEVS..... the people who are putting us in this position are literally laughing all the way to the bank and not even on this damn subreddit in the first place...
* **Gaming as a hobby vs gaming as a career**
   * If you are on this subreddit, I don't have to tell you about how magical the game dev process is. It's incredible. But doing something as a hobby and doing something to make money are two different things.
   * Am I going to play AI slop that has no soul in it? 
      * No. I don't play bad games, period, with or without AI.
   * Do I hate the AI bros who are like: "BrO I OnE ShOT ReD DeAD ReDEmPTion 6 on My Ps2 HeHE - GAMe DeVs Are So COoKed"?
      * Yes, a lot.
   * What should you do as a hobbyist? 
      * DO ANYTHING! Have fun, this is a magical process. Learn things from a textbook, or a video, do it by hand or with your feet, it doesn't matter, its a HOBBY - FOR FUN! Do what feels right and moral and nice for YOU
   * What should do as a commercial project? 
      * DO WHAT WILL MAKE YOU MONEY. You will STILL have to make a great game to have financial rewards in this crushing industry. And that is VERY VERY VERY HARD! Everyone flooding Steam Fest will soon realize gamers have a good nose for bullshit, and that we will not play garbage slop. 
   * Am I going to play a game that is heavily assisted by AI, if the developer(s) poured their hearts and souls into it? 
      * Yes.
      * "but what about the copyright infringements/energy/water/noise pollution etc?" valid concerns, but this refers me back to my first point about capitalism: we live in a shit world. The tools that already existed before AI were also made by companies that exploited people too... Are we forgetting how Epic laid off a terminally ill employee? How many of us are still on Unreal? Or better yet, how many of us still use products every single day that are manufactured companies that are doing horrible things around the world? I am not saying we need to stop fighting back, far from it, but we can't exit the system completely unless you want to live like *Into the Wild.* The more interesting point, IMO, is WHO do we target our frustration at. 
      * "how can you pour your soul into a game if you are assisted by AI?" AI is a tool with pros and cons, just like a spreadsheet or a game engine or a video editor. Getting assisted by a tool doesn't automatically mean something is bad. Its very easy to do something bad. Doing something legitimately good (with standards of quality that are continuously increasing because of these very tools) IS HARD
   * Can you ignore games that touched AI whatsoever? 
      * OF COURSE, feel free to play whatever you want! There are gazillions of games out there, choose all the non-AI stuff YOU love.
   * Do I think WE (game developers trying to have fun and/or make a living in this insane situation) should shit on EACH OTHER, other individuals who are trying to have fun and/or make a living in this space? 
      * NO!

  
I was motivated to do this post because I have been a software engineer for 8+ years on a boring corporate job, and like everyone here I love games and making them. I've done game jams and worked on personal projects, but finally I got to a point in my life where I want to try putting something on Steam...   
  
and then... I come on Reddit/YouTube....   
  
and its civil war + getting hit by a tsunami of shit + the ground is changing under our feet as we speak.

I've said a lot... this was a mess of a brain dump, thanks for reading if you are here, so I'll try to conclude briefly with what I really want to say:

If you are like me, thinking about how to make it work as a solo dev in this chaotic and cruel world, and you are feeling anxious and depressed - you are definitely not alone. Keep going. Make a great game. Use the tools at your disposal. Put the same effort that you would, with or without AI, and, like always, hope for the best. At no point in time was success a guarantee, far from it, but don't let the negativity get to you. If this is truly what speaks to you, then go all in and do whatever you can to make it happen.

And also maybe don't be in the internet for too long... this thing really gets us down sometimes.

document fetched 2026-10-31 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xj9nmd/old_man_yells_at_cloud_takes_on_ai