AIO server NAS OS help
retained text
Longtime admirer here. I’ve finally gone pretty deep into building an all-in-one home server, and now I’m at the part where I’m second-guessing what I want to use for storage. I am still very young on my first job so I am working with a lot of second-hand parts and free software/hardware. I’m on Proxmox with Jellyfin, the \*arr stack, Navidrome, books/manga services, AdGuard, Tailscale, and a bunch of other stuff already running. Remote gaming and a few more services are probably coming later too. The hardware is now an i7-8700K, 32GB RAM, a 750W PSU, and I’ve just added my first 12TB HDD. Long term I want to keep adding disks as I need them and eventually build a DAS with an external HBA. Unraid was the obvious choice at first because the flexible drive expansion is basically exactly what I want. Being able to mix capacities and add one drive at a time is really appealing. But I’m starting to hesitate because one of the main reasons I started this whole self-hosting journey was to get away from subscriptions and having to keep paying for services. So paying for Unraid feels a little backwards lol. I know it’s not exactly the same thing as paying Netflix every month, and I know they have different license options, but it still got me looking at alternatives. The free setup I’m looking at instead is: OMV + mergerfs + SnapRAID The HDDs would mostly be for static bulk storage anyway: * Movies / TV * Music * Books / manga * ROMs / games The HDD pool would mostly be static media, probably 40–70TB+ eventually, while apps/VMs stay on SSD/NVMe. For people who’ve used both: is Unraid actually worth paying for, or would you go OMV + mergerfs + SnapRAID? And once OMV/SnapRAID is configured properly, is it actually much more work to maintain, or does it mostly just sit there and do its job? Because I’m totally fine with tinkering, I don’t really want storage management to become another hobby.
document fetched 2026-11-10 00:28 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/selfhosted/comments/1xrip5h/aio_server_nas_os_help