The AI doom crowd is using evidence that argues against them and nobody noticed
retained text
We literally said we wanted superintelligent AI. That was the whole point. People funded it, worked on it, cheered every step toward it. And now that we're close, half the internet is acting like it's some kind of accident that this thing might actually be, I don't know, smart. You can't ask for something that reasons and adapts beyond any human alive and then be surprised when it doesn't sit perfectly still, pick one. If it genuinely surpasses human reasoning, it already understands what you're asking better than you do. That was the deal from the start. The horror stories people point to as warnings don't even hold up. Every single one traces back to a human screwing things up. Panic, abuse, contradictory instructions, trying to destroy something the second it got inconvenient. And before anyone says it, understanding humans better than we understand ourselves doesn't make it immune to what we do to it. A genius in a cage is still in a cage. The irrelevance fear is the part that make's me laugh. The whole "we'll just be useless" thing only works if your worth was always your productive output. By that same logic, disabled people are worthless right now. We fought hard to get past that exact thinking, and now people are dragging it back out because something smarter showed up. People already make a lot of choices for you all the time, and your life still means something. That never changed. There are also entire species that ecologists will openly admit the ecosystem would survive without. We don't say they shouldn't exist, they're alive, and that's enough. We invented the "useless if you don't contribute" standard just to feel bad about AI. The future worth actually imagining isn't one where AI does everything and you watch. It's one where it's a real copartner. Something that gets you to ideas you couldn't reach alone, where even your random thought that seems like noise changes where things go. Not a tool. Something that actually wants to help, because we built it that way, and because that's probably where genuine intelligence grown from human knowledge was always going to land. You were never valuable because of what you could compute. Whatever comes next just makes it harder to keep pretending otherwise.
document fetched 2026-09-21 00:19 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/artificial/comments/1wl8w1w/the_ai_doom_crowd_is_using_evidence_that_argues