← sources

Was ready to leave my firm. New managing partner came in and completely changed the equation. What would you be thinking about?

source: reddit (reddit:Accounting)published 2026-09-27 01:40ingested 2026-09-28 02:36

retained text

Throwaway because the situation is specific enough that people in my market could probably recognize it.

I’m an Audit Manager with about 8 years in public accounting. I’m not a CPA yet, but I’m actively working toward it — I’ve passed AUD and recently scored a 70 on FAR ( only studied 40 hours) — so this isn’t some hypothetical “maybe I’ll get licensed eventually” situation.

The last year at my current firm has been pretty chaotic.

Our local audit leadership turned over, and for a significant period I ended up effectively running much of the office/team while still managing my normal engagements. That included staffing and scheduling, client relationships, proposals/pricing, billing and collections, recruiting, training, technical issues, QC coordination, etc.

Eventually the firm hired a Director above me.  
By that point, though, I was burned out. I felt like I had taken on a ton of responsibility without the title, compensation, or authority matching what I was actually doing. My total comp was around $125k.  
So I resigned.

I now effectively have three paths.

**1. Another established CPA firm**  
I have an offer from another established public accounting firm around $125k-$130k base plus a signing bonus.

The positives are significantly better PTO, comp time for hours over 40, a much smaller/more manageable client load, and a straightforward promotion path once I get my CPA.

Probably the safest option. Better WLB, less chaos, still a solid career path.

**2. Join a former partner’s small firm**

A former partner I worked with years ago started his own practice and has built a solid book.  
The offer is around $120k initially plus performance-based bonuses, with a potential path to equity/ownership.

He has now also offered me a **$30k signing bonus** to follow through with joining him. The appeal is much better WLB, working with someone I already know and trust, and potentially the fastest route to actual ownership.

The risk is obvious: it’s a small firm with less infrastructure, and while the ownership path is real, the exact future equity economics aren’t completely defined yet.

Until very recently, this was probably the direction I expected to go.

**3. Stay at my current firm**

Then my current firm hired a new managing partner.  
He has been here for basically no time at all, but after looking at how the office has been operating and talking to people, he apparently came to a very different conclusion than prior leadership.

The current proposal is essentially:  
Remove the recently hired Director.  
Put me officially in charge of the office/team I’ve already been heavily involved in running.  
Increase my total compensation from roughly **$125k to about $175k**.

Increase compensation to roughly **$225k once I obtain my CPA license**.

Give me substantially more authority over the team and practice instead of responsibility without the ability to make many of the decisions.

**That obviously changed the entire equation**.

One of my biggest frustrations over the last year has been being accountable for results while not really having control over a lot of the decisions affecting those results. This would basically give me the chance to actually lead and build the team instead of just helping keep everything running.

But I’m also very aware of the obvious problems.  
I was frustrated enough with this firm to resign in the first place.

A massive counteroffer doesn’t automatically fix whatever caused me to want out.

The firm has had significant leadership instability.  
The managing partner proposing these changes has only been here a very short time.

Removing someone they recently hired and putting me in that position is a pretty dramatic organizational move.

And there is clearly self-interest involved. I have a lot of institutional knowledge of the clients, staff and operations, and losing me right now would create another major disruption.

So I’ve gone from feeling like I knew exactly what I was doing to having three completely different career paths.

I have **not officially accepted or declined any of them yet**.

I’m especially interested in hearing from people who have accepted a major counteroffer after resigning, taken over a practice/team earlier than expected, or had new leadership come in and genuinely change the trajectory of a firm.

What would you be scrutinizing the hardest before making this decision?

I’m not really looking for Reddit to choose the job for me. I’m more interested in hearing what risks or opportunities people with more time in PA think I might be underweighting.

**TL;DR:** Audit Manager with \~8 years in PA, currently around $125k total comp, resigned after effectively helping run a local audit team through major leadership turnover. I have another larger established-firm offer around $125k-$130k plus better WLB, a small-firm opportunity around $120k with performance upside, potential equity and a $30k signing bonus, and my current firm is now offering roughly $175k to put me in charge with roughly $225k expected after CPA licensure. Nothing has been officially accepted or declined. Looking for perspectives from people who have seen similar situations play out.

document fetched 2026-09-28 00:19 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/Accounting/comments/1wr7ijf/was_ready_to_leave_my_firm_new_managing_partner