How do you tell if Claude agrees with your idea because it’s good?
retained text
I use Claude a lot for coding and architecture, and the thing I find hardest to judge is whether my approach is actually good or whether I’ve just put it in the prompt. If I explain my solution and ask for alternatives, it usually comes back to mine. Even when I explicitly ask it to challenge me. Maybe I’m right sometimes. But then what did I get from asking? I’ve started giving Codex the same problem without showing it my solution or Claude’s answer. That gives me another starting point, although now I’m the one deciding between two convincing explanations. I’m an architect, talking through trade-offs is a big part of why I use these tools, so this bothers me more than a coding mistake I can catch with a test. Has Claude changed your mind about a technical decision recently? What did it point out that you’d missed?
document fetched 2026-09-18 00:22 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ClaudeAI/comments/1wj14bf/how_do_you_tell_if_claude_agrees_with_your_idea