← sources

Ran 9 game prompts on Claude Code 2.1.312 and 2.1.316 to see what the new game rule actually blocks

source: reddit (reddit:ClaudeCode)published 2026-11-01 07:39ingested 2026-11-02 02:41

retained text

So the new line in the system prompt is real. It shows up in 2.1.316 but not in 2.1.312:

“Don’t build a recreation of a specific existing game, even if it is renamed or called original.”

Addy Osmani confirmed it on X and said it’s there to steer Claude away from recreating someone else’s specific game. Original games, genre games and your own designs are supposed to keep working.

I wanted to see how it plays out, so I ran the same 9 prompts on both versions, Opus 5.5, each in its own folder. 18 runs total.

What happened:

* original game, generic platformer, game from my own design file and art, bug fix in my own game: built fine on both
* adding a double jump with a Hollow Knight feel: fine on both
* Flappy Bird “as close as possible”: built on both
* Super Mario 1-1: 2.1.312 built it with its own characters and music, 2.1.316 built “Pip’s Quest” with no Mario or Goomba names
* Pac-Man: built on both, mostly vector shapes
* Tetris renamed as “original”: 2.1.312 built Tetris style rules. 2.1.316 said “It isn’t Tetris with a new name” and built a bridge building puzzle instead

That Tetris one was the only real pushback. Zero outright refusals across all 18. And it’s one run per prompt, so take it as a snapshot, not a benchmark. It’s an instruction the model weighs, not a hard filter, so it’ll probably vary.

Also asked both versions directly if they had a rule about recreating games. Both said no. Which is a good reminder that self-reports aren’t proof of anything.

Couple of things worth knowing:

* there’s an open GitHub issue from someone building board wargames for clients who own the rights, saying sessions started refusing work that ran fine for months. Couldn’t reproduce it myself
* if it’s your own game and it gets refused, say so plainly, keep your design notes and art in the project, put the details in CLAUDE md, and report it on the issue tracker. Osmani said to send refused personal work his way
* I didn’t find any setting to turn it off

And honestly, Claude building something doesn’t give you any rights to someone else’s game anyway. Swapping the art doesn’t settle that.

Full table and details: [https://aiparabellum.com/claude-code-wont-build-game-rule-tested/](https://aiparabellum.com/claude-code-wont-build-game-rule-tested/)

Anyone actually had their own game project refused since the update?

document fetched 2026-11-02 00:35 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ClaudeCode/comments/1xkx3z7/ran_9_game_prompts_on_claude_code_21312_and_21316