← sources

Whitelisting Request

source: reddit (reddit:sysadmin)published 2026-09-24 14:46ingested 2026-09-25 02:41

retained text

I already have my answer for how to handle this, but I'm curious how many of you have seen a request like this and what your reaction was. (maybe I'm just an a-hole)

The company I'm working with regularly receives file feeds from (usually) payroll processing companies via SFTP.  Nothing crazy there.  A little SFTP, a little PGP/GPG, done.  But there are 2 such large companies that regularly send us a list of \~70 IPs they want us to whitelist for them to send the files.

Now, if someone sends me a /29 CIDR block I don't think too much off it.  But when you send me multiple /27 blocks my immediate response is "f\*\*\* off".

I can't believe I'm the only one that responds as such.  Yet it keeps happening.

Edit:  
It's not the act of punching in the IPs one by one or something.  I could use CIDR notation.  It's that whitelisting way more IPs that are actually necessary isn't exactly best practice.  Much less THAT many more.  I can all but guarantee they actually utilize 1 or 2 in those blocks.

Edit 2:  
I have ZERO internal push back on this.  In fact, internally we've all had a good chuckle about it and push back saying - Nope.  Refine that list and get back to me.  It's just a head scratcher that this seems to be their (the vendor) SOP and that they haven't gotten enough pushback to refine their process.

document fetched 2026-09-25 00:40 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/1wp3n1z/whitelisting_request