← sources

Q3 2026 insider trading: notable buys came after the multiple collapsed, big sells came at peak margins

source: reddit (reddit:ValueInvesting)published 2026-10-20 12:27ingested 2026-10-21 02:41

retained text

Insiders sold $21.0B and bought $923M, a $22.79 to $1 ratio across 5,121 sellers and 1,371 buyers.

**Most of the selling isn't a valuation call.** 51 sellers did 45% of the dollars, the median seller sold $475K, and 413 insiders sold every month of the quarter. The two biggest names:

* NVIDIA director Mark Stevens sold $947.6M while the trailing P/E fell to 25.2 (lowest since 2019) and operating margin hit a record 65.2%. That's selling into a cheaper, more profitable company, which fits diversification better than a bearish view.
* Bezos sold $346.5M of Amazon. Amazon's trailing P/E of 19.0 looks like its cheapest since 2009, but Q2 nonoperating income was $53.4B against $27.5B of operating income, and trailing free cash flow was -$11.6B on $173.0B of capex. The low P/E is mostly an earnings-quality question.

**The buys, with the valuation each insider paid**

|Company|Insider buy|P/E (TTM)|What the filings show|
|:-|:-|:-|:-|
|Boston Scientific|CEO, $9.0M at $48.33 (first since 2014)|17.1, down from 63.4 a year earlier|Record 19.8% operating margin; EPS $1.70 to $2.49; growth guidance cut twice|
|Uber|CEO, CFO, COO: $16.9M|15.2|Record $10.1B free cash flow (6.9% yield); 2.6% fewer shares|
|Dick's|6 insiders, $5.1M at \~$130|20.7, up from 13.9|Revenue +53.5% with Foot Locker, operating income -21.6%|
|GameStop|Cohen, $57.3M in Sept|10.9|Record 13.5% operating margin, revenue still down 7.7%|

**Has insider buying been a useful margin-of-safety check before?** For these six stocks, 2009 to 2026, I compared each quarter's next-12-month return with the stock's own median quarter. Quarters with insider buying beat the norm 59% of the time (median +6.4%) vs. 46% without. Buying after a 30%+ drop beat it 71% of the time (+38.5%, 17 quarters), while the same drops with no buying beat it only 40% of the time. Two surprises: $1M-plus purchases did no better than small ones, and buys made while operating margin was falling did better (+16.3%) than buys while it was rising (+0.3%).

By that history, Boston Scientific (55% below its prior-year high) and Dick's (42% below) are the setups that have worked; Uber is borderline at 28% below, and GameStop doesn't fit at 6% to 18% below.

Which looks like the better value buy to you: Boston Scientific's rising margin at 17x, or Dick's falling margin at 21x?

document fetched 2026-10-21 00:44 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xaqsza/q3_2026_insider_trading_notable_buys_came_after