← sources

My “professional” listing got 6 clicks. “Stop selling cookies on marketplace lol” got 65. $0 spent, 8 weeks, 14 makers signed up. The exact playbook, and the 5 years of mistakes before it.

source: reddit (reddit:EntrepreneurRideAlong)published 2026-10-21 00:27ingested 2026-10-22 02:38

retained text

Building it was the easy part. Getting everyone to look at it is the part I’m bad at, so here’s what I’ve got so far.

**Where it’s at, week 8 of attempt 2**

* 14 of 25 founding spots taken (sourdough, grass-fed beef, tallow skincare)
* $0 ad spend
* Revenue: $0, on purpose for now
* Team: me & wifey, nights and weekends

**What it is**

People’s Pantry. A free online ecommerce space for makers who sell locally or ship it with a focus on tackling the complexities of local food: home bakers, farmers market makers, the small farm with a chest freezer. Pickup, local delivery, and shipping built in. No monthly fee, no listing fee.

The problem I kept seeing: these makers are good at what they do, and the only place they sell online is Facebook, where they do order math in DMs and live or die by the algorithm.

**The 5 years before this**

Started poking at it November 2021. Website up in 2022. Hired a developer to build the parts I couldn’t, and he basically stole from us. Cost a lot of time and $.

About two years ago we onboarded our first small group of makers. His payment calculations were wrong, among a lot of other things. The makers quit. Can’t blame them.

I couldn’t fix it myself, and I wasn’t going to onboard a new group just to hand them the same bugs. So I stopped and learned Laravel. Took about a year. Everything live now is code I can read.

Attempt two started about two months ago. Kept going because I love building this.

**The experiment**

Before building more, I wanted feedback. So I used Facebook Marketplace as a recruiting tool instead of a sales tool: listings aimed at sellers. About 30-35 listings over 8 weeks across a few cities.

**What flopped vs what worked**

Round one, late August:

* Feature-style titles → 2 to 6 clicks each
* “Free storefront if you bake from home” → 41
* “Stop selling cookies on marketplace lol” → 65
* “Free store for anyone who sells homemade food” → 91, and 3 messages

Round two, mid September, same playbook, near-identical titles:

* “Stop selling food through DMs lol” → 0
* “Free store for anyone who makes food at home” → 0
* “Your food is good enough to sell, you just need the store” → 1
* “Farmers Markets Are Ending, Keep Selling Your Food Online” → 7
* “Sell Your Homemade Food Online, Free Store, Free Delivery Setup” → 0

Nothing got rejected. Every one still says Active. Marketplace just stopped showing them to anyone. Happy to DM more info, screeshot in body.

Either it flagged the second batch as duplicates of the first, or it figured out I was listing an offer and not a thing. The insights panel only gives you clicks, saves, and shares, no impressions, so I can’t tell which from the data. Running a test to find out (below).

**The playbook, if you want to copy it**

1. List it as Free. I put $12 on a few in round two. For a free store. Anyone browsing free listings never saw them.
2. Title = the seller’s identity or their pain, in their words. Not yours. “lol” beat every proper sentence I wrote.
3. One real-looking photo. Stock worked fine. The one with our logo and a QR code on it got zero, looks like an ad because it is one.
4. One listing per city you’d actually serve, and change the title, photo, and first line for each. I ran the same copy across cities in round one and got away with it. Round two I got zeroed. Don’t be me.
5. Write a real description with the link in it. See below.
6. Check it weekly and kill anything under 10 clicks.

**What I got wrong**

1. I used “cottage food” everywhere because that’s the industry word for food made in a home kitchen. Regular people had no idea what I meant. Dropped it from the titles. It’s still sitting in the keyword junk under two of the round two listings. Yeah.
2. I ran weeks of listings with no link in them. All that interest and nowhere to send it. Then I relaunched and still didn’t put the link in. Rookie, twice.
3. The descriptions are keyword walls. “sell food online, homemade food store, free online storefront, food vendor platform.” The round one listings that got messages had an actual sentence in them. I know this and the live ones still look like that.

**Money**

None right now. The plan is optional paid promotion for makers, a dollar a day or so, to get their stuff in front of more people. Not sure that’s right. I don’t want to nickel-and-dime people selling cookies. For now there’s a donate button. Tell me I’m wrong.

**Next**

Two things.

One clean Marketplace listing: new title, new photo, a real description with the link, $0, one city. If it moves, round two died because I copied myself. If it sits at zero, the account is cooked for now and that’s its own lesson. A week from now I’ll know.

And Saturday market, in person. Get the vendor with the longest line to say yes. Their regulars follow. That works one market at a time. It doesn’t scale past the markets I can drive to.

**The question**

Think of this as a $0-fee ecommerce platform that actually understands local food. If you’ve built a free tool for one specific kind of small seller, how did you get it in front of them at scale? Market organizers, maker communities, referral loops inside the product, something I haven’t thought of? Ads are on the list, but I’d rather hear what moved the number for you without spending.

Not linking it. It’s in my profile if you want to poke at it. Week 12 update either way.

document fetched 2026-10-22 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EntrepreneurRideAlong/comments/1xb8s9l/my_professional_listing_got_6_clicks_stop_selling