One contract of gold, ES and NQ are three different sized bets, so my cross market test was partly a sizing test
retained text
I ran one breakout completely unchanged on NQ, ES and gold a few weeks ago, 15 minute candles from January 2021 to September 2026, 100k account, one contract each. It came out up 20% on NQ and down 54% on gold. A commenter pointed out the thing I should have caught myself, which is that **one contract is a different amount of risk on every market**. A full NQ contract moves $20 per index point, ES moves $50 per point, and gold moves $100 for every dollar the price moves. A stop that sits a sensible distance away on each chart turns into a different dollar amount on each one, so the three legs of that test were never taking the same risk per trade. That means some of the gap between plus 20 and minus 54 could just be **sizing**, and a fixed contract test cant tell you how much. The cleaner version sizes every trade so the stop costs the same dollars on all three markets and only then compares them. Its like comparing two delivery drivers on fuel cost when one drove a pickup and the other drove a hatchback. The route matters and so does the vehicle, and you have to even out the vehicle before the route tells you anything. For anybody running this on an eval the number to look at changes as well. A trailing drawdown doesnt care where the account finished, it cares about **the first day it touched the loss limit**, so that date belongs beside the final return in any comparison like this.
document fetched 2026-10-20 00:43 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/algotrading/comments/1x9jmzd/one_contract_of_gold_es_and_nq_are_three