← sources

At what point do you guys actually trust a deal enough to commit it?

source: reddit (reddit:sales)published 2026-10-31 15:29ingested 2026-11-01 02:38

retained text

Commercial SaaS AM here. Had a new SMB colleague who recently got promoted ask our new manager when you should actually commit a deal to your forecast. Everyone laughed but it did get me thinking since.. it's just something that I had to learn on my own rather than a concrete framework so thought I could use a refresher myself.

We've all had those deals where the customer seems excited, loves the product, says all the right things… and then disappears into the Goodfellas witness protection program with Henry Hill.. 

For those who've been doing this a while, what's your **actual gut check** before committing a deal on the weekly forecast calls to close by a certain date? Because ya know no matter what your manager says about not holding your feet to the flames, your face is gonna end up eating shit when the VP gives him shit on the last day of the quarter for not bringing it in. 

Are you looking for specific buyer actions, a mutual close plan, budget confirmation, or just enough *je nais se quois* to know when someone's full of shit? 

Curious how you all separate real momentum from pink cloud of wishful thinking and whether there is a process that you follow now.

document fetched 2026-11-01 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/sales/comments/1xkd54f/at_what_point_do_you_guys_actually_trust_a_deal