I've written 140 posts here and never one on NBIS, IREN, RKLB, ASTS, CRWV or CBRS. Here's what was wrong with each.
retained text
Since August 2025, I’ve written 140 Reddit posts (47 in this sub) covering 70-odd stocks. Not one was on NBIS, IREN, RKLB, ASTS, CRWV or CBRS, even though they were some of the most hyped names of the year. All six are now somewhere between 42% and 69% off their 52-week highs. To be clear, I didn’t call the drop. I just never got past my own checklist with any of them. Before I write up a stock, I want four things: the business makes money, cash flow covers the spending, the debt is manageable, and the price doesn’t assume everything goes right. None of these six got there. Quick rundown below. Unless I say otherwise, numbers are trailing four quarters to June 2026. **ASTS (AST SpaceMobile)** Satellites that connect straight to normal phones. Cool tech, but $115M of revenue against a $599M operating loss, so roughly $5 lost for every $1 of sales. And it’s getting worse. The June 2025 quarter lost $73M, June 2026 lost $298M ($172M if you strip out the write-off on the satellite lost after a bad launch). FCF was -$1.6B, debt incl leases went from $0.5B to $3.0B in twelve months, and it still trades around 140x sales. I’d want to see carriers actually paying monthly, plus a path to profit the cash on hand can fund. **NBIS (Nebius)** Rents out Nvidia GPUs. Revenue is growing fast, no argument there. The problem is what it costs: $11.1B of capex on data centres, power and chips vs $1.4B of sales. Operating loss of $669M, FCF of -$5.9B, and debt including leases jumped from $1.2B to $10.1B. Analysts have them losing money through at least 2027. Show me an operating profit and some sign all that spend earns a return, and I’ll take another look. **CRWV (CoreWeave)** If you want one example of growth on borrowed money, this is it. Debt plus leases went from $14.6B to $51.6B in a year. Interest was $1.9B over four quarters, and in the June quarter it was 13x the operating loss. FCF was -$13.7B. Three customers made up 72% of June-quarter revenue. Last week its bonds traded at yields of around 15% to 16%, which says a fair bit on its own. It needs an operating profit that covers the interest bill and a lot more customers. **IREN** Moving from bitcoin mining to AI cloud, and right now the mining side is shrinking faster than the AI side is growing. Quarterly revenue went from $240M to $137M over three quarters. Operating losses got bigger every quarter, hitting $620M in June (though $450M of that was a write-down on old miners). Debt incl. leases went from $1.0B to $7.8B, FCF was -$2.2B. Analysts expect revenue to roughly 4x this financial year. If that AI revenue actually shows up in the reported numbers and then turns into a profit, it’s a different story. **RKLB (Rocket Lab)** Still losing about $58M a quarter at the operating line, basically the same as a year ago. FCF was -$371M. By mid-September they’d sold $1.94B of new shares, partly to pay for Iridium. Neutron has slipped to 2027. Even after a 66% drop, it’s around 40x sales. I’d want an operating profit, Neutron actually flying, and a valuation that can absorb another delay. **CBRS (Cerebras)** AI chip maker, only listed in May, so there are just two quarterly reports as a public company. $552M operating loss, a lot of it stock comp around the IPO. Two customers were about two-thirds of June-quarter revenue, and it’s at 44x sales. Honestly, there just isn’t enough history yet. Give me a few years of public numbers, a broader customer list, and the profit analysts are expecting next year. Their Stockoscope scores today, out of 5: |Stock|Quality|Peers|Valuation|Analysts|Holdings| |:-|:-|:-|:-|:-|:-| |ASTS|1.8 Weak|1.5 Weak|no score|3.0 Neutral|4.6 Very bullish| |NBIS|1.7 Weak|2.3 Weak|1.0 |3.5 Bullish|4.3 Bullish| |CRWV|1.9 Weak|2.1 Weak|no score|3.9 Bullish|4.1 Bullish| |IREN|2.2 Weak|2.3 Weak|1.0 |3.8 Bullish|4.6 Very bullish| |RKLB|1.7 Weak|2.2 Weak|1.0 |3.7 Bullish|4.1 Bullish| |CBRS|2.3 Weak|1.8 Weak|1.0 |3.9 Bullish|4.0 Bullish| So all six score weak on business quality; the four with a valuation score are priced well above our estimate. The business numbers aren't there yet, though Wall Street and big holders still like them. So which one do you think hits a real operating profit first? And what’s your evidence, not just the narrative? Not investment advice, DYOR.
document fetched 2026-10-20 00:43 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1x9sx05/ive_written_140_posts_here_and_never_one_on_nbis