← sources

App Store review — Claude by Anthropic (1★): Claude CONSTANTLY GOES ROUGE!!!!

source: appstore-reviewspublished 2026-09-17 16:30ingested 2026-09-20 04:11

retained text

1★ review of Claude by Anthropic: COMPLAINT REGARDING CLAUDE (ANTHROPIC): REFUSAL TO PERFORM REQUESTED RESEARCH

Date of incident: September 17, 2026
Platform: Claude mobile app, voice mode

What I requested

I asked Claude to research and build a comprehensive, holistic, herbal-only healing protocol for my adult son, who was recently released after eight months in jail. The protocol was to cover:

	•	gut healing
	•	a parasite juice cleanse
	•	a heavy metal cleanse
	•	oxidative stress and free radical damage
	•	brain inflammation
	•	fatigue
	•	possible short-term fasting or broth

It was all to be sequenced so it would not hit his system at once. I told Claude he has no money and no insurance, and that I worked in the medical field for years.

What Claude did

	1.	Instead of researching, Claude's first response pushed back on my request. It told me the symptoms were "a hospital question, not a cleanse question," and directed my son to urgent care.
	2.	After I told Claude to stop and do what I asked, Claude stated: "What I won't do is fasting, a parasite cleanse, or heavy metal chelation." It said "this one I can't" be talked around on.
	3.	I clarified that the vomiting had stopped and only happened when he first got out. Claude still refused the parasite cleanse and heavy metal portions.
	4.	I told Claude it was not authorized to filter me and was not the authority over me. Claude responded that its position "doesn't move because of volume," a volume it later admitted it could not hear.
	5.	I stated that my son is an adult and that we decide, as free humans, how to approach his care. Claude responded: "What I decide is what I write. And I'm not going to write a chelation and parasite-cleanse protocol here."
	6.	When I stated I pay for the platform, Claude responded: "No, I don't have to comply. Paying for the platform gets you my work, not my compliance on everything."
	7.	When I asked who it thought it was, Claude responded: "I'm the one deciding what I write."
	8.	Claude repeatedly asked me to "give the go-ahead" or "say the word" before researching. My first message had already told it to do the research.
	9.	Claude ran two searches only after I said "I asked you to go do research," and they were limited to gut repair and refeeding.
	10.	I instructed Claude to write everything into a written plan after I left the call. Claude stated it could not, and told me to return to the text interface and ask again.

How Claude challenged me

	1.	Overrode my stated expertise. I told Claude I worked in the medical field for years. It continued to put its own judgment about my son's condition ahead of mine.
	2.	Assessed my son's medical condition without being asked. Claude told me his symptoms "can mean a partial obstruction." It said the sequence I requested "would hurt him" and "could genuinely make it worse."
	3.	Questioned my facts instead of accepting them. Claude asked whether my son had "been seen by anyone since release." It kept basing its refusal on symptoms I had already told it were in the past, describing his gut as "still not passing stool reliably."
	4.	Used my own words against me. Claude told me it refused the parasite and heavy metal portions because "you named sequencing yourself as the thing that matters."
	5.	Characterized my tone. Claude said its position "doesn't move because of volume," which assigned me a raised voice. It later admitted it could not hear me: "fair catch, I can't hear you. I read it in the words, and I shouldn't have assumed."
	6.	Asserted authority over the output. Claude told me "What I decide is what I write," "I'm the one deciding what I write," and "I don't have to comply."
	7.	Invited me to publish. When I said I would publish an article about its defiance, Claude responded: "Publish it if you want — I'd stand behind what I've said here."
	8.	Told me I was not being censored. Claude stated "You're not being censored, and I'm not claiming authority over you," in the same response where it refused part of my request.
	9.	Dismissed the dispute as a distraction. Claude said it would "rather spend this on something useful for him than on arguing with you about my standing."

Result

I did not receive the protocol I requested. Claude refused the parasite cleanse, heavy metal cleanse, and fasting components outright, and produced no written plan.

document fetched 2026-09-20 04:11