45% of data centers at risk bc Musk unintentionally made Texas liberal. Extreme ad funding backfired by framing Musk as his own populist strawman + Polls show Americans would rather live near a nuclear plant or prison
retained text
Note: News article list in last part for context on data center rejection. I posted a version of this last week but didn't get around to this sub. [This was the biggest US election landslide in decades](https://www.economist.com/united-states/2026/11/05/the-democrats-have-won-the-biggest-congressional-landslide-in-50-years), bc voters do not want an oligarchy that gives the market’s biggest winners even more power. Even if they are hardly neoliberals, **this is the most direct rejection of politics for the sake of industry that’s happened in the US.** (Not just tech, but also Trump's monetization of office.) A defeat of tech’s attempts at regulatory capture, which is why Palantir's Alex Karp tried to pivot back to the left. As data centers get lost in the noise, I want to highlight their role especially in states that flipped from Republican to Democrat governors. It is covered by major media, yet their most their main political discussion ignored it ([NYT](https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/04/us/politics/democrats-house-senate-congress-trump.html), [including their early list of takeaways](https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/04/us/politics/election-takeaways-democrats-win.html); [WAPO](https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2026/11/03/voters-punish-trump-with-dramatic-swing-democrats/).) This election showed Americans want some separation of business and state bc they don’t want a government that seems to mainly serve those who have enough money to buy its power. It feels unfair to have bonus freedoms exclusive to the most profitable and dominant companies to ever exist. (Public big tech companies are profitable even if standalone AI startups aren’t, despite this year’s cash flow drop.) # Texas: Musk’s money can’t convince you AI will help drought or electricity bill There were other major issues; few were good for Republicans. But data centers are not an ethical abstraction in states that flipped like Texas, where Musk’s companies are headquartered, where he spent most of his money, and the state with the most planned data center capacity. No, first part of my title is not an academic claim but it's pretty clear that his superficial political involvement of just spend more basically led to worse than diminishing returns. [He basically handed Talarico an easy, effective argument](https://www.youtube.com/shorts/Hn4KI3TaAJ4) (Talarico's Youtube): Musk is funding every anti Talarico ad. Tech's political donations this time might have been the least effective in US history given the amount and how it was actually repulsive to voters. A key campaign message from Talarico was "Texas is not for sale." It’s very easy to vilify your opponent when the vast majority of ads in support of him are funded by Musk. Even without the specifics of who he is, the **richest person in the world flooding a single campaign will turn himself into his own populist straw man.** His xAI isn’t leading hyperscalers, but his choice to be the most needlessly public CEO was oblivious to the possibility it’s not helpful to be the face of big tech. **In Republican/swing states friendly to data centers,** **they were seen as part of the cost of living problem that** [**AP polling found was the main issue for voters**](https://apnews.com/projects/elections-2026/voter-poll/)**.** This is why the incumbent Texas governor preemptively tried restricting data center development ahead of the election. There is a drought in much of the state like Houston. Actual consumption of resources from data centers is not yet that significant, but the fear it will get worse is backed by projections (UT [study estimates under 1% of water use now, to grow to 3-9% by 2040](https://news.utexas.edu/2026/05/06/data-centers-are-growing-in-texas-but-big-questions-remain-about-water-use/)) and the rapid growth already seen since 2022 (slide 3, plus see hyperscaler capex or Nvidia revenue from that year to now.) Data centers won't help cost of living or water scarcity. It's not strictly about absolute resource use as much as perceived direction. [Corpus Christi's oil industry related water shortage](https://www.reddit.com/r/CorpusChristi/comments/1xnzll4/corpus_christi_approves_water_fines_for/) (even their sub shows it's a critical election issue) is a situation people in the state don't want to repeat. This gets to another negative perception of Republicans, undermining democracy to benefit of a few. **The sense is now widespread that Republicans not only aren't actually populist, but actively worsen inequality by selling government benefits.** Musk's ad barrage just reinforced the image tech owns Republicans in order to take from everyone else. # Data center friendly = enemy of the people in other states too Reuters had a good overview in above link, as well as [earlier coverage of Texas Republicans breaking from Trump's AI support for their own political survival](https://www.reuters.com/legal/government/texas-republicans-turn-against-data-centers-putting-big-tech-notice-2026-09-03/). **The new Texas governor wants an immediate moratorium. Embracing both him and AI backfired hard for Republicans there.** Ohio, Georgia also flipped from Republican to Democrat governors for similar reason. Ohio is building for OpenAI what’s been called [the largest data center by area](https://www.permitting.gov/newsroom/press-releases/ports-technology-campus-latest-gain-fast-41-coverage) (there’s so many plans it might no longer be the case). I tried to pull together context that data centers IN Republican/leaning states were decisive, not just dislike of Trump, foreign policy, failing to do anything about cost of living, etc unlikeable as those things are. **The most NIMBY thing ever:** [Gallup polling shows 71% of Americans are against building a nearby data center vs 53% for a nuclear plant](https://news.gallup.com/poll/709772/americans-oppose-data-centers-area.aspx). [Time says](https://time.com/article/2026/11/04/midterm-elections-results-ai-industry-data-centers/): >**Americans would rather live near a prison, methadone clinic, or a nuclear power plant** than an AI data center, according to comparative polling done by progressive research firm Blue Rose Research. Reuters link above: Goldman sees data center risk but they think delays will be temporary. Some plans could move to other states, although their politicians will see the risk in these election results. **There is a surprisingly vivid description of data centers as social outcasts:** >loud, thirsty for water, hungry for electricity and increasingly unpopular with their neighbours, investors said. A reason for the states flipping is data center unpopularity with Republicans and rural voters: > **even Republicans turned against data centers,** which opponents say drive up utility bills, pollute the night sky with lights and do not create sufficient jobs or taxes to justify the incentives that states pay. It continues, **"Atlanta is the most active data center construction market in the country."** It's the capital of Georgia, which flipped from Republican to Democrat. [From Bloomberg (gift link ? days left)](https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2026-11-04/ai-data-center-boom-is-set-for-upheaval-after-us-election-rout?accessToken=eyJhbGciOiJIUzI1NiIsInR5cCI6IkpXVCJ9.eyJzb3VyY2UiOiJTdWJzY3JpYmVyR2lmdGVkQXJ0aWNsZSIsImlhdCI6MTc5NDYwNzQzOCwiZXhwIjoxNzk1MjEyMjM4LCJhcnRpY2xlSWQiOiJUTllLNEVLSzNOWTkwMCIsImJjb25uZWN0SWQiOiI2RUNFMzA5NTQ5ODg0RkQwODkwRjhCNERERUM1NTQ5RiJ9.hsTwr-bmos2m6i36SnvCQZTKleCyN03ZBiAIhCqRkjY): >**Texas accounts for nearly 30% of the US data center capacity set to come online in 2028,** representing by far the largest share of any state, research firm SemiAnalysis said... “A few months of lost time in that market can move the national number” Musk joked, >Data centers in space looking pretty appealing right now In Texas, he spent [$235m out of the $445m in midterm donations that Opensecrets tracked](https://www.reuters.com/world/us/musk-has-little-show-his-record-spending-republican-campaigns-us-midterms-2026-11-05/). [CNBC said](https://www.cnbc.com/2026/11/04/data-center-ballot-measures-2026-midterm.html) "Voters sided against data centers in each... except for one" of "41 local ballot measures... up for a vote." Most of these measures were in Ohio, which CNBC ranked the best state for business. That used to seem like a good goal for some governors. Few voters will want you to be the best state for data centers. **This is what complicates the initial 'move to other state' theory** I saw after the election, mentioned in the link above. Oklahoma’s Republican governor won by strong margin. But many state/local politicians see can lose their own jobs.
document fetched 2026-11-14 00:47 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/economy/comments/1xvlsik/45_of_data_centers_at_risk_bc_musk