My boss is making me feel guilty for accepting a job offer somewhere else. Did I make a mistake?
retained text
I’ve been at a small CPA firm with five accountants for three years. It’s my first PA accounting job, and I currently make around $54k, including a Christmas bonus. I have no benefits or health insurance. I recently accepted a hybrid offer at a larger and known firm for $75k base, plus a $5k–$7k+ annual bonus depending on my tax-season hours, bringing total compensation to around $80k–$82k. The benefits aren’t bad, and I see more opportunities for professional growth. I was genuinely excited because I’m solo parenting and this year I went through a very expensive divorce and essentially had to rebuild my life from scratch three years ago. It has been expensive and I’ve been doing it all with the little I make. I need to increase my income, support my son, and build a career that allows me to advance. The problem is that my boss has made me feel incredibly guilty about leaving. She says she built me and while I appreciate everything she taught me, I feel like I’m not getting the experience I need after three years. We don’t accept new clients and work needs to be distributed very well so that everyone has work. I do more of the little bookkeeping jobs and during tax returns a lot of 1040s but I help around in other things just not enough for me to even remember what I worked on. Making it hard to continuously see a corporate tax return from start to finish. Something I can do but definitely don’t feel comfortable doing it alone. During interviews for other accounting positions, I was repeatedly told that my skills weren’t translating well enough for senior accountant roles. I still received offers, but for lower-level positions paying $75k–$80k. That reinforced what I already suspected and it was that I need more exposure and development if I want to advance. After I accepted the new offer, and I told my boss… she told me she planned to raise my pay to $30/hour in December and increase my vacation from two weeks to three. That made me question whether I was making a mistake. At my current firm, I can bank the additional hours I work during tax season as PTO. This past season, I accumulated the equivalent of three weeks off by working those extra hours. My boss argues that I’m trading time with my son for nothing by leaving because no other employer will give me that flexibility. She called me Friday to ask whether I’ve spoken to the other young accountant, she wanted to know if she was happy. (she ended up offering that person the same raise she had discussed with me) I don’t want to seem ungrateful. But I also want to grow and make more money. After 3 years of PA and a masters degree, people are making well above what I’m making. And when I tell you this past year I struggled with bills I’m not exaggerating. I’m studying for the CPA exam, and I’m already struggling with sleep, concentration, and finding enough energy to study. This entire situation has made all of that even harder. Now I’m scared that I traded flexibility and time with my son for a more demanding job. But I’m also scared that staying means remaining underpaid and professionally stagnant. I’m scared that my expectations of myself are also unrealistic, maybe I’m not supposed to know a corporate tax return. I can figure it out with prior year work but I’m not confident in my abilities at all. I feel horrible. And I’ve cried about this more than I like to admit. I asked her if we could talk about it when I heard her talk about $30 and hour and basically told me that if I accepted their offer it meant something about them made me not think of her and that was enough for me to leave. I told her I can always cancel on my offer. I’m hoping that by discussing it here or venting I’m able to feel a little better because I genuinely think I’m depressed, I can’t concentrate to study and I have one week left to start the other job.
document fetched 2026-10-13 00:18 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/Accounting/comments/1x3zs2h/my_boss_is_making_me_feel_guilty_for_accepting_a