Apple Secretly Creating Knowledge Graphs?
retained text
I just read about this (link to the original article below). Apple has been secretly building a knowledge graph of its many-billions of users since 2022. And now it's partnered with Google. 51 SQLite databases. 181 entity classes. 278 relationship types. Your contacts, your routines, your inferences. No toggle. No opt-out. No disclosure at onboarding. In 2022 that was a privacy concern but in tooday's AI everywhere world it's something else entirely. Apple has since partnered with Google (probably the most predatory data company on earth) and has not published when, under what circumstances, or whether any of this inferred data ever leaves the device. Not a single public document. So we have a system that builds a graph of your life, a partnership with a company whose entire business model is extracting value from graphs like that, and zero visibility into the boundary between "on device" and "off device." The comment section on AppleInsider's breakdown says what we're all thinking: "I have incredibly strict NDAs with most every client I have... Having Apple decide to intrude on my private communications and build this plain text file is so far beyond alarming, I can't even find the words." — u/paul4work One commenter pushed back: "This is data on my device, being analyzed by my device, and which stays on my device. I don't see how this is fundamentally any different from Spotlight indexing." Maybe. But Spotlight indexes files — I control what gets indexed, I can exclude directories. This is a model making probabilistic inferences about my relationships using architecture I can't inspect, and Apple has not told us the conditions under which its own models might send any of it anywhere. It would be far less concerning if the user owned the intelligence. My device, my model, my inferences, my rules. Then I could say "yes, look at everything, because it's mine and I wrote the policy." But you can't have your cake and eat it too. Build the graph, partner with an advertiser, withhold the disclosure, and then call it private. Thoughts on this? Here's the original article: [**https://appleinsider.com/articles/26/11/08/how-apples-personal-knowledge-graph-learns-about-your-life-on-mac**](https://appleinsider.com/articles/26/11/08/how-apples-personal-knowledge-graph-learns-about-your-life-on-mac)
document fetched 2026-11-11 00:38 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/privacy/comments/1xsv7i4/apple_secretly_creating_knowledge_graphs