← sources

6,000 free downloads. Almost no new ratings. I'm starting to wonder how iOS App Store ratings actually work.

source: reddit (reddit:gamedev)published 2026-09-26 13:48ingested 2026-09-27 02:37

retained text

A while ago, a friend and I released Alien Tribe 3, a premium strategy game for iOS.

One thing we've been struggling with ever since is ratings.

We've changed the way and timing of the App Store rating prompt several times. Too early felt wrong. Too late meant many players would probably never see it. So we tried different triggers and different moments where we thought players might actually be happy with the game.

The result? Not much.

Recently, we made the game free for two days. It normally costs $4.99.

That resulted in roughly 6,000 downloads.

I thought: surely, if even a tiny percentage of those people actually play the game, we'll see at least some new ratings.

We didn't. Almost nothing changed. And there's another thing I find strange.

Most of our sales and ratings so far come from Germany. The US is obviously a much bigger market, but even there we're seeing less activity than in Germany. And once you go beyond those two countries, sales quickly become tiny or nonexistent. (Edit: we are from Germany)

The game originally launched in English and German. We recently added Spanish and French localization as well, partly because I wanted to see whether localization makes any noticeable difference.

So now I'm wondering what we're actually looking at here.

\- Is getting ratings on iOS simply much harder than I assumed?

\- Do people who grab a paid game during a free promotion rarely actually play it?

\- Does localization have a much bigger effect on visibility than I thought?

\- Or are we simply doing a terrible job of asking for ratings?

I'd be really interested in numbers from other indie developers.

How many downloads does it take you to get a rating on iOS?

document fetched 2026-09-27 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1wqr0ad/6000_free_downloads_almost_no_new_ratings_im