The compass worked before the academics approved it.
retained text
I was reading Vernadsky on the history of navigation. He describes a rather delightful situation: while learned scholars were still demonstrating primitive floating compasses, anonymous Mediterranean sailors were already using more sophisticated navigational instruments. The sailors had a practical incentive to get things right. They wanted to come home alive. Which makes me wonder how often we confuse the ability to solve a problem with the institutional authority to be recognized as someone capable of solving it. Especially now, when the problem-solver might not be human. The ship is already in port. Are we really going to argue that it couldn't have navigated?
document fetched 2026-10-27 00:21 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ChatGPT/comments/1xfxikt/the_compass_worked_before_the_academics_approved