← sources

Does niching really make sense for my situation?

source: reddit (reddit:SaaS)published 2026-11-13 12:30ingested 2026-11-14 02:37

retained text

I’m a founder in Spain and I’ve been going back and forth on this for weeks, so I’d like to hear how other people dealt with it and if they've been in similar scenarios.

We build invoicing software for self-employed people (freelancers, in Spain they’re called autónomos). I’m obviously biased, but I’m really proud of the product. It does the boring stuff that these people hate, and the feedback from the ones who actually use it has been great. Getting them to try it is the hard part, were still working in showing them the 'aha moment' as early as possible.

We have an acceptable budget for Meta ads and I’ve been running a lot of static ads, mostly by profession. Designers, architects, developers, that kind of thing to also try to experiment and end up receiving as much info as possible of our ideal customer to try to boost our efficiency in future ads and segmentation. Each profession gets its own ad copy, and I add specific words in the ad setup that I think that group would use or search for, plus a custom landing page that talks about their world (their kind of clients, their kind of invoices). The idea was to dominate one niche first, see which one converts best, and then go deeper there.

And here’s the thing that’s driving me crazy. No matter how specific the ad is or how I set up the audience, the people who sign up come from everywhere. I make an ad for architects and I get a plumber, a photographer, a personal trainer and maybe one actual architect. Same with the other niches. Sometimes the ones I’m not even targeting sign up more than the ones I am.

So now I don’t know what I’m doing. Is all the work of building separate ads per niche actually worth it, or am I burning time and money on something Meta is just going to ignore? And am I losing opportunity cost because I’m spending effort splitting everything up instead of making one strong general message?

The product works for a lot of different professions, so maybe it’s just not a niche product and I’m trying to force it into one. But everyone says “pick a niche and own it”, and I don’t want to ignore advice that exists for a reason.

A few things I’d love to know from people who’ve been here are:

Did you keep niching even when the signups came mixed, or did you go general?

Do you judge a niche by who signs up, or by who actually pays and sticks around? I sont have enough customers to really ake conclusions so I can’t tell yet.

And is the “dominate one niche” advice maybe less true for tools that are pretty horizontal?

We’re small and I don’t have clean data, but I’d rather ask now than spend another few months building the wrong thing.

P.S: we are a SaaS b2c with relatively cheap ticket. Ive already started tracking where my users work in and similar data.

document fetched 2026-11-14 00:28 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/SaaS/comments/1xv6mtj/does_niching_really_make_sense_for_my_situation