Earned the Bestseller badge, but disappeared from search again
retained text
It’s me again, sorry for having so many questions! Algorithms are driving me crazy, and it feels like I am spending more effort dealing with them than actually creating products. Last time, I asked about my listing being reindexed after I updated the title. Luckily, it jumped back to page 1 after two days, and I officially earned the Bestseller badge today! However, something weird is happening now. I usually search in an Incognito window to check if my listing is on the 1st page for a broad search term (my goal right now is to have it consistently stay on page 1 for the most competitive search terms). My sales are still coming in. In fact, I am making more sales today than before. But when I search for it in Incognito mode, I can’t find the listing anywhere, even after browsing through several pages. It’s the same story for a few other search terms too. I can only see it when I search for the exact specific title. Strangely enough, I can still see my less popular listings, just not the bestseller that’s generating the most sales. I am really curious about what’s going on here. The algorithm is stressing me out!
document fetched 2026-09-28 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1wr8sb1/earned_the_bestseller_badge_but_disappeared_from