Next Fest got me 423 wishlists. One YouTuber got me 284 in a single day. How cooked am I?
retained text
Solo dev from Germany, making Sails of Salt, a singleplayer pirate roguelite in Godot. Next Fest just ended, and the most interesting number isn't from the fest at all: **Next Fest brought me 423 wishlists in a week. One YouTube video brought me 284 in a single day.** I'm at 1,041 wishlists now, with a launch planned for Q1 2027. Here's the rest. **The creator part** I wrote personal emails to 65 creators. Seven wrote back, one made a video: a 10-game roundup that gave me a small bump. Then on Oct 3, CaRtOoNz (4M subs), a channel I had never written to, found the demo on his own and played it for 72 minutes. There was no Steam link in the description, so people typed the name into Steam search by hand. My baseline was 1 to 5 wishlists a day. That day I got 284. **Next Fest itself** About 60 wishlists a day during the fest. Depending on which slice of Chris Zukowski's survey you look at, that's a bit above or a bit below the median for games that walked in with my numbers. So: normal. Next Fest amplifies what you bring, and I didn't bring much. My capsule got about 49k impressions on the fest page, and 2.5% of those clicked. **The demo** The demo seems to hold people. Across the \~830 who have played it so far, the median is 35 minutes, 37% played more than an hour (Steam says that's above average for demos), and 1 in 10 played more than five hours. But 4 out of 5 fest wishlists came from people who never played it. So I don't think the demo is my problem. Getting people to see it is. **The math that worries me** If I fall back to 1 to 5 a day, I'll launch with somewhere between 1,200 and 1,800 wishlists. Everything I read says you want 5k or more. And a game only gets one Next Fest, so there's no second one to save me. **Questions:** 1. Launch in Q1 anyway, or push the date and try to grow more? 2. Was doing Next Fest now a mistake? Should I have waited until I had more visibility? 3. How do you find the next CaRtOoNz? Big channels that do long videos on a single game don't seem to answer email. Do you approach them differently, or just hope they stumble over you? 4. If you were in Next Fest: what click-through rate did you get on the fest page? I can't find a benchmark anywhere. So, how cooked am I? Steam page, if you want to judge the game yourself: [https://store.steampowered.com/app/5084680/](https://store.steampowered.com/app/5084680/)
document fetched 2026-10-28 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xgr0wp/next_fest_got_me_423_wishlists_one_youtuber_got