ICLR 2027 rebuttal: two of three reviewers haven’t responded, sitting at 2.67 (3/3/2). Anything left to do? [D]
retained text
My ICLR submission got 3/3/2. In the rebuttal we added new theory that addresses the main concern all three reviewers shared, plus the baselines they asked for. One reviewer replied that all their concerns were addressed and the work is strong. But kept their score. The other two, including the one who gave the 2, haven’t responded, even after a follow-up. As the Rebuttal closes tomorrow, Is it worth one more note to the AC? Do ACs ever weigh the rebuttal when reviewers go silent, or is 2.67 basically a reject and I should move on to the next deadline?
document fetched 2026-11-18 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/1xz0020/iclr_2027_rebuttal_two_of_three_reviewers_havent