← sources

Amazon got sued for lying about your ad auction for seven years

source: reddit (reddit:ecommerce)published 2026-09-24 12:43ingested 2026-09-25 02:38

retained text

Hi redditors! The FTC and 22 states sued Amazon on August 31 over what you paid for your ads.

You all know how a second price auction works. You bid two dollars, the next guy bids one, you pay a dollar and a cent. You never pay your own number.

The FTC says that stopped being true in 2019. Amazon added what it called a soft reserve price, and its own executives described it in internal documents as an invented auction participant. A bidder that doesn't exist, sitting in your auction, pushing you up to your ceiling.

The numbers in the filing are the part nobody quoted. In 2021, 30 to 40% of Sponsored Products ads charged the advertiser their full bid, in 2022 it was 70%, by 2024 around 80%.

You couldn't see it, because you can't audit an auction you don't run. Your own report still shows something. Compare your average CPC to your max bid, campaign by campaign, and see how close they sit. It isn't proof on its own, a tight auction does the same thing, but it tells you where to look.



I've barely run Amazon myself, a couple of client accounts and that's it. If you sell on there, what's your read on this?

document fetched 2026-09-25 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ecommerce/comments/1wp0mkn/amazon_got_sued_for_lying_about_your_ad_auction