I switched my mail server plans from Mailcow to Stalwart – an honest comparison (Oct 2026)
retained text
I've been running my own mail for a while. My first setup was Mailcow, and for my homelab I've now decided to go with Stalwart. Before switching I compared both in detail, so here's the short version. Maybe it helps someone facing the same decision. **Mailcow** * ~15 containers: Postfix, Dovecot, Rspamd, SOGo, ClamAV, MariaDB, Redis, Nginx… * Official minimum is 6 GiB RAM + 1 GiB swap, 8 GiB recommended for 5–10 users * Everything included: webmail, CalDAV/CardDAV, ActiveSync, antivirus * Battle-tested components, big community, roughly monthly releases * LXC isn't supported, needs a full VM **Stalwart** * One Rust binary: SMTP, IMAP, POP3, JMAP, CalDAV/CardDAV/WebDAV, spam filter, ACME * ~100 MB RAM idle, 1 GB is enough for 5–10 users * Pluggable storage (RocksDB, Postgres, S3…) * JMAP support is great if you like building your own tools * **But:** still 0.16.x, 1.0 isn't out yet. No built-in webmail (planned after 1.0), no built-in AV, some features are Enterprise-only. Read the release notes before updating – one recent update needed manual ALTER TABLE on MySQL/MariaDB setups. **Why I picked Stalwart:** my Proxmox host runs lots of other services, and I'd rather give my mail server 1 GB than 6+. One process, one log, one config fits how I like to run things. And I barely use webmail anyway. **Why you might still pick Mailcow:** you want everything (webmail, AV, calendar) working out of the box today, you host mail for non-technical people, and you have the RAM. One thing applies to both: neither will fix your deliverability for you. Check outbound port 25 before you start, and set PTR records for IPv4 **and** IPv6. Gmail rejected my mail until the IPv6 PTR was set for the exact address, not just the /64. I wrote up the full comparison (table, pros/cons, who should pick what) on my blog. It's in German, but browser translation handles it fine: https://frickelfabrik.de/blog/stalwart-vs-mailcow/ Curious about your experience: anyone running Stalwart in production yet? How did your Mailcow → Stalwart migration go?
document fetched 2026-10-24 00:30 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/selfhosted/comments/1xd9ubc/i_switched_my_mail_server_plans_from_mailcow_to