SFI Delhi’s Instagram appeal sat “under process” for six weeks. The Delhi HC has set a three-week window.
retained text
Donate Now **tl;dr** On 24 September 2026, the Delhi High Court disposed of a petition filed by the Students’ Federation of India (SFI) and Sooraj Elamon, Secretary of its Delhi State Committee, directing the Grievance Appellate Committee (GAC) to decide their pending appeal within three weeks. The appeal concerns Instagram’s disabling of u/sfidelhi, an account with approximately 13,000 followers. The Court’s order concerns the delay in deciding the appeal. **Background** SFI Delhi had used u/sfidelhi since August 2018 to communicate its activities, share information about student campaigns and engage with students and the wider public and the account had built an audience of approximately 13,000 followers before it became inaccessible. On 5 July 2026, Instagram suspended the account and its notice stated that the account “may be associated with another account that has gone against our rules”, citing its Community Standards on account integrity. The notice did not identify the other account or explain the conduct said to violate those standards. The petitioners appealed through Instagram that day. On 7 July, Instagram rejected the appeal and permanently disabled the account. It stated that the account still did not comply with its standards on account integrity, without providing particulars of the alleged violation. On 9 July, the petitioners submitted a complaint to Meta’s Grievance Officer. Meta acknowledged receipt and assigned a complaint number, but its email contained general reporting links rather than a response to the disabling of u/sfidelhi. The petition states that no substantive resolution followed. On 12 August, the petitioners filed Appeal No. 147178/2026 before the GAC. More than a month later, the portal continued to show the appeal as “under process”. They approached the Delhi High Court in Students’ Federation of India & Anr. v. Union of India & Anr., W.P.(C) 14084/2026, seeking a decision on the appeal, a process consistent with their constitutional rights, and restoration of the account. **Analysis** The Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021 establish a grievance process for users of intermediaries such as Instagram. Under Rule 3(2)(a)(i), as amended in February 2026, the Grievance Officer must acknowledge a complaint within 24 hours and resolve it within seven days of receipt. While Meta acknowledged this complaint, the petitioners’ grievance is that the acknowledgement was not followed by a substantive response explaining or addressing the account’s disabling. An acknowledgement alone cannot fulfil the duty to resolve a complaint. Now, as per Rule 3A allows users to approach the GAC when they are dissatisfied with a Grievance Officer’s decision or their grievance remains unresolved within the prescribed period. Rule 3A(4) requires the GAC to deal with appeals expeditiously and endeavour to resolve them within 30 calendar days of receipt. So, as per the rule’s wording requires an endeavour to meet that timeline. It does not justify leaving an appeal pending without a decision. In this case, the petitioners had completed both the platform’s internal appeal and its formal grievance process before approaching the statutory appellate body. The Hon’ble High Court of Delhi heard the matter on 24 September 2026 and it recorded the limited grievance pressed before it that the appeal had been pending since 12 August and no order had been passed. Counsel for the Union of India stated that the appellate authority would be advised to dispose of the appeal expeditiously, preferably within three weeks from that date. The Court disposed of the petition “expecting the Grievance Appellate Committee to decide the appeal filed by the petitioner, within a period of three weeks”. It also preserved the petitioners’ liberty to pursue appropriate legal remedies if any grievance remained. **Action** For a student organisation, losing an established account cuts off a means of reaching people who have chosen to follow its work. Creating another account does not restore that audience or the record of earlier campaigns. Where the stated reason is an association with an unidentified account, users are also left without the information needed to contest the decision. The petition argues that permanent bans require clear reasons and an effective opportunity for human review. We support these safeguards for users irrespective of their political affiliation. Platforms should explain the conduct that prompted a restriction and give users a fair opportunity to respond. Earlier this year, in Subodh v. Union of India & Anr., the Delhi High Court also required the GAC to decide a pending Instagram appeal. Users should not have to approach a constitutional court simply to obtain a decision from the appellate mechanism established for them. MeitY should examine the causes of these delays and publish information on pending appeals and disposal times, along with decisions subject to appropriate protection of personal information. We will continue to assist the petitioners in pursuing their appeal before the GAC and assess any further legal remedies in light of its decision. We will share updates on the proceedings. The petitioners were represented by Advocates Apar Gupta, Pragya Jain, Naman Kumar and Sahil Mander. If your account has been blocked or taken down due to a government order please reach out to us for pro-bono legal support at [legal@internetfreedom.in](mailto:legal@internetfreedom.in) **Important Documents** 1. Delhi High Court order dated 24 September 2026 in W.P.(C) 14084/2026. 2. IT Rules 2021 updated as on 10 February 2026. 3. IFF’s update on Subodh v. Union of India & Anr., dated 25 May 2026. Donate Now
document fetched 2026-10-13 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/india/comments/1x402vg/sfi_delhis_instagram_appeal_sat_under_process_for