← sources

Tesla Model Y – Lease vs. Buy Through S-Corp (California, ~80% Business Use) – Which Is Better Tax-Wise?

source: reddit (reddit:Accounting)published 2026-11-03 17:42ingested 2026-11-04 02:36

retained text

I’m a physician in California starting a medical S-corp and trying to determine whether it makes more sense to lease or purchase a Tesla Model Y, primarily from a tax perspective.

Here are the details:  
Vehicle: 2026 Tesla Model Y Premium RWD  
Purchase price: Approximately $52,850  
Estimated business use: 70–80%  
Estimated annual mileage: Approximately 5,000 miles  
Business structure: California S-corp  
Vehicle would be used primarily for business purposes, with some personal use.

I’m considering two options:

**Purchase/finance:** Finance the vehicle and have the S-corp own it. Potentially take advantage of Section 179, bonus depreciation, and/or regular depreciation, subject to applicable limitations.

**Lease:** Have the S-corp lease the vehicle and deduct the business-use portion of the lease payments.  
My questions:

From a tax standpoint, which option generally provides the larger deduction over the first 3–5 years?  
How do Section 179, bonus depreciation, and the passenger vehicle depreciation limitations affect a Model Y?

Are there any significant disadvantages to purchasing through an S-corp versus personally owning the vehicle and having the corporation reimburse business mileage?  
How does personal use affect deductions, depreciation recapture, and reporting?  
Are there any California-specific tax considerations I should be aware of?

I’m less concerned about monthly cash flow and more interested in maximizing legitimate tax deductions while minimizing my overall after-tax cost of ownership.  
Would appreciate feedback from CPAs or tax professionals who have experience with physician-owned S-corps and business vehicle deductions.

document fetched 2026-11-04 00:18 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/Accounting/comments/1xmzm09/tesla_model_y_lease_vs_buy_through_scorp