← sources

Nvidia vs AMD vs TSMC . Which is the value buy ?

source: reddit (reddit:ValueInvesting)published 2026-11-13 13:38ingested 2026-11-14 02:42

retained text

If AMD takes a big order Nvidia was hoping to win, TSMC can still get paid to make the chips. That’s why TSMC is the business I’d most like to own. At the November 12 U.S. closes, though, I’d rank the stocks Nvidia first at $166, TSMC second at $405, and AMD third at $585. I’m sitting out all three for now.

AMD is third, and it just had the kind of quarter that makes me want to buy it. Data-center sales nearly doubled to $8.5 billion, and management expects about $17 billion in total sales next quarter. Big customers are already using its new Helios systems. Then I do the math. If AMD earns the $17.69 per share Wall Street expects in 2027 and investors pay $33 for every $1 of profit, the stock comes out to $584. AMD can have the excellent year analysts expect and leave me roughly where I started. [AMD’s earnings release](https://ir.amd.com/financial-information/sec-filings/content/0000002488-26-000188/q32026991.htm)

I’m also watching how much of AMD’s growth reaches each share. Cash left after equipment spending fell from $1.56 billion to $554 million from one quarter to the next. And OpenAI and Meta could buy up to 320 million new shares if their deals hit certain targets. That’s about a fifth of AMD’s current share count. Those deals could make AMD a much bigger business. At $585, I want to see how much more cash that bigger business leaves for each share. [AMD’s quarterly filing](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/2488/000000248826000191/amd-20260926.htm)

TSMC is second, and it’s the one that makes this a close call. October sales rose nearly 60% in Taiwan dollars, and the company has about $91 billion in cash and liquid investments after debt. At $405, I’d pay about $27.50 for every $1 it earned over the past year, against a ten-year average of about $23. Its U.S. shares also cost roughly 14% more than the equivalent Taiwan shares at their respective closes, which happen at different times. Much of its production is still in Taiwan, and management expects overseas factories to take three to four percentage points off gross margin over the next few years. I get $215 when I value the cash TSMC could generate after paying for those factories. I’ll have been too cautious if the new plants fill faster and earn better margins than I expect. [TSMC’s quarterly results and call](https://investor.tsmc.com/english/quarterly-results/2026/q3) · [October sales](https://investor.tsmc.com/english/monthly-revenue/2026)

Nvidia is first because I get more profit and cash for the price I pay. Sales more than doubled to $96.2 billion last quarter. Customers use its chips, software, and networking together, so switching can mean reworking the whole setup. At $166, I’m paying about $10.50 for every $1 analysts expect Nvidia to earn in the fiscal year ending in early 2028. Take investment gains out of the past year’s profit and I estimate I’m paying closer to $24 for every $1 it earned. That’s a lot of growth to count on. [Nvidia’s earnings release](https://investor.nvidia.com/news/press-release-details/2026/NVIDIA-Announces-Financial-Results-for-Second-Quarter-Fiscal-2027/default.aspx)

Then there’s Jensen Huang. He helped decide which chips to build, how much supply to lock up, and which customers Nvidia would help finance. Since he stepped down, I’ve cut what I assume investors will pay a year from now from $18 to $16 for every $1 of profit. I kept my earnings estimate at $12.76 per share. With the same allowance for excess cash, that takes my one-year estimate from $238 to $212. If investors only pay $12 for each dollar of profit, I get $161. Nvidia could earn exactly what I expect and I could still lose money at $166. [Nvidia’s leadership announcement](https://investor.nvidia.com/news/press-release-details/2026/NVIDIA-Announces-CEO-Transition/default.aspx)

Nvidia and TSMC are closer than the ranking makes them look. My middle case gives Nvidia 27% over the next year and TSMC 12%. Once I weigh the good and bad outcomes, that narrows to about 8% versus 7%. Give the bad outcome a little more weight and TSMC moves ahead. Nvidia has the clearer edge over five years, where my middle case gives it 17.3% a year, versus 11.6% for TSMC and 10.1% for AMD. The returns below include estimated trading costs and dividends where applicable. In the first table, trailing means the past 12 months, and P/E is the price paid for each dollar of annual profit.

|Metric|Nvidia|TSMC|AMD|Winner|
|:-|:-|:-|:-|:-|
|Latest quarterly sales and growth from a year ago|$96.2B, +106%|$46.7B, +41% in USD|$13.4B, +45%|Nvidia|
|Gross margin · what’s left after direct costs|75.0%|66.4%|54%|Nvidia|
|Operating margin · what’s left after running the business|66%|58.7%|21%|Nvidia|
|Latest quarterly earnings per share growth|\+128%|\+69% in Taiwan dollars|\+95%|Nvidia|
|Trailing reported earnings per share|$7.91|$14.77 per U.S. share|$4.61|—|
|Trailing P/E vs. 10-year average|21.0× vs. 54×|27.5× vs. 23×|127× vs. roughly 90–94×|Nvidia|
|P/E on Wall Street earnings estimates for late 2027 or early 2028|10.5×|17.8×|33.1×|Nvidia|
|Trailing free cash flow yield · cash after equipment spending per $100 invested|$3.20|$2.10|$0.70|Nvidia|
|Cash and liquid investments less debt|$23B|$91B|$9B|TSMC|
|Annualized dividend yield at the latest payout, before tax|0.6%|\~1.3%|None|TSMC|
|Share-price return over the last 60 trading days|−23.6%|−1.6%|\+25.5%|AMD|
|Distance below the 52-week high|−31.7%|−16.8%|−11.1%|AMD is closest|

|My estimates from these prices|Nvidia|TSMC|AMD|
|:-|:-|:-|:-|
|One-year net return if things go badly|−50%|−42%|−72%|
|One-year net return in my middle case|\+27%|\+12%|−26%|
|One-year net return if things go well|\+109%|\+53%|\+28%|
|One-year net return after weighting those outcomes|\+8%|\+7%|−34%|
|Two-year total net return in my middle case|\+57%|\+30%|−1%|
|Five-year net return in my middle case, per year|17.3%|11.6%|10.1%|
|Ten-year net return in my middle case, per year|12.4%|7.0%|7.5%|
|What I think the future cash is worth per share today|$131|$215|$235|

I haven’t bought any of them. Around $130 is where I’d take another serious look at Nvidia. With the same earnings and risk assumptions, that’s where my one-year scenarios average the 40% return I’m looking for after costs. The same math gives me $309 for TSMC and $275 for AMD, both still above what I think their future cash is worth. When Nvidia reports on November 17, I’ll pay more attention to what Colette Kress says about the next quarter. The quarter she’s reporting ended before Huang left. If Rubin is shipping on time and customers are paying on time, I can get more comfortable. If the stock hits $129 because orders are slipping, I’ll redo the numbers before buying. [Nvidia’s earnings date](https://investor.nvidia.com/news/press-release-details/2026/NVIDIA-Sets-Conference-Call-for-Third-Quarter-Financial-Results/default.aspx)

document fetched 2026-11-14 00:48 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xv83z0/nvidia_vs_amd_vs_tsmc_which_is_the_value_buy