← sources

I’ve stopped caring and maybe that’s a good thing?

source: reddit (reddit:EtsySellers)published 2026-09-20 02:29ingested 2026-09-21 02:36

retained text

For context, I have a popular listing in the clay/pottery community for mahjong tiles. It’s a set of 5 ranging from $16-18. But there’s  also the option for a blank tile (after requests so people could make an identical size tile with a bright color and add it to the back for charms, earrings etc).

I had a buyer only purchase the blank and then get upset at me because she didn’t get the full set of 5. There are options you select - and she selected “Blank” for $3.00. Anyways, she messaged me and asked for a refund, which I agreed to if she shipped back the item (my shop policy is no refunds so I told her I’d make an exception). When I wouldn’t also pay for return shipping she left a mean review. I replied to the review just saying I shipped what she ordered and I’m sorry it wasn’t what she was expecting.

I also added more context to the listing description about ordering a blank vs a set of 5 embossed tiles.

Ok so I randomly get another order for a blank tile - nothing else in the order - even though I’ve sold tons of these, it’s usually never the only thing in the order. I should have messaged the person but didn’t - anyways, now she’s also arguing with me asking for me to send the whole set because of deceptive advertising and how it happened to someone else.

Is it terrible to just not care? I told her to try buyer protection for a refund - but that I printed and shipped exactly what she ordered so it wouldn’t be eligible for a refund on my side.

Will buyer protection assist her? I realize she’ll write a bad review but I kind of just stopped caring. I sell hundreds of these and it just feels like the weirdest coincidence. 

It’s $3.00. I could absolutely refund this (not what she requested though - she wanted me to print and ship all the embossed tiles) but I think I’m at my customer service limit. Anyone else ever feel this way? 

(If it matters - 23k sales with 4.9 stars - most talking about my excellent customer service)

document fetched 2026-09-21 00:25 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/EtsySellers/comments/1wl4qcr/ive_stopped_caring_and_maybe_thats_a_good_thing