← sources

My game was a small hit, but I was stupid

source: reddit (reddit:gamedev)published 2026-11-11 13:39ingested 2026-11-12 02:38

retained text

I want to preface this by saying that my intention with this post is to simply tell a story about my journey as a game developer. I understand that I have taken quite a few bad decisions; you don't need to remind me, though I guess I can't stop you. My intention is mostly so that people can learn from my mistakes, even though for some people they might be obvious; they obviously weren't for me at the time.

I come from a web development background (both frontend and backend); all of this way before AI was a thing, even before things like WIX and Squarespace were popular. At some point in 2020 or 2021 I got an Oculus Quest 2 and fell in love with the experience of VR. Naturally, I decided that I wanted to create a VR game.

Now, in my mind I simply wanted to create a game (though not a simple game), I didn't think too much about marketing, sales, and all of that. At that point my intention was more "pure" if I can describe it like that. That made me take some questionable decisions, like using an engine that (at the time) barely had support for VR (Godot 3).

So, in summary, I decided to make a game, my first game ever, which was going to be a VR game in an engine that wasn't notoriously famous for 3D games, let alone VR. Needless to say, I was climbing an almost vertical hill lol

In any case, I pushed forward. At some point I realized that I wasn't going to be able to complete the game, so I switched to making the first 30 or so minutes of the game. You could call it a vertical slice or a demo, and then I would decide what to do depending on the reception of the game.

I'll spoil you a little; it took me about a year to make the demo. If you see the final result, you could say things like: "I could make this in a month" or something like that. Keep in mind that this was my first game ever. First time touching an engine and so on. In any case, I got it done. I can't back this up, but I believe my game was the first or one of the first games made with Godot in the Meta (at that time Oculus) store.

However, the game took my sanity away. By the end, I can say from the bottom of my heart that I ABSOLUTELY HATED THE GAME. I despised it. In my mind, it was the most boring and disgusting piece of trash that I had the displeasure of experiencing. I don't say this just to say it; at the time the only thing that I wanted was to finish it so I could throw it away and never look at it again. I really, really hated it. I guess I got burned out. I worked on it Every. Single. Day. Even if it was just for a minute or two, I made sure to do it (big, BIG mistake)

So, after a year I released it, made a few posts about it and kind of let it be. There wasn't that much interest, and I believe I got like a player or two a day for a few weeks or months and then I stopped looking.

Then something unexpected happened. Every so often I checked the stats on the dashboard just to see, and suddenly I saw a spike of about 1-2 thousand new players a day. This was like a year or so after I released the demo, not sure. I was shocked. I tried to find if there was a video or article or something that mentioned the game, but couldn't find anything, and I'm still not sure what caused the initial spike.

Those numbers kept consistent for quite some time. Right now the demo is sitting at about 180k unique players (unique players that have launched the game at least once). For quite some time, people were emailing me daily saying how they loved the game and couldn't wait for the full release.

The attention I suddenly got kind of overwhelmed me. I wasn't expecting people to enjoy so much something I honestly hated. Some people even played the demo for 6 hours or more, even though the demo was designed for about 30 minutes of gameplay.

This post is already longer than it should be, so I'll try to omit a few things, not because I think they are not interesting, but because it's just too damn long lol

So... what did I do with that sudden amount of attention? Nothing. By the time the spike happened, I didn't hate the game as much, but I can't say I liked it. I still had some type of grudge with it. I wish I could say that I did an "Among Us" and revived the game, but I just didn't do it. If we are being logical, I was stupid to just let it burn. People were writing me daily to ask when the full game was coming out, and I just... Did nothing. Not for laziness, but I guess I just wasn't in the right state of mind at the time, even if it sounds stupid or ridiculous or whatever. I couldn't get myself to touch the project again.

Since then, I made a few more games, but in the next games I did something that I knew I shouldn't have: I played it safe. I was afraid of them becoming a failure, and well, they became a failure for that very reason. I stopped creating because I wanted to create and switched to a more "business" or safe mindset, but bad business to be honest. I even tried to create a game similar to my first game, though again, I wasn't creating something I really wanted, it was more something I felt like could work based on the thing that initially worked, but it didn't have the "soul" of the first game.

Now I'm working on my last game (maybe). It doesn't even have a Steam page, so I won't promote it or anything, but what I can say about it is that at this point, I don't really care if it flops or if it's a hit. I want to create something that makes me feel what the first game made me feel (minus the burnout, of course). I'm taking risks, adding stuff that some people will say it's pointless or stupid or whatever. I'm doing things that some people will absolutely not like and that's ok. At the very least, I will feel good with what I created, and not feel like I'm walking on thin ice with every decision I take. If people don't like it then it becomes a failure like the other games, but a failure that I can say I like at least.

So, if you want to take something away from this post, I'd say: don’t burn yourself out and create for the sake of creating. Success may or may not come, but at least you'll feel good with whatever you end up creating.

I don't *really* regret anything though. I believe that everything that happened in my journey so far has helped me become a better developer and person even. I've worked with some amazing people and done things that past me would be proud of! Mistakes and all.

That's it, that's my story as a not-really-successful game developer. Though I do have to say, I do consider the first game/demo a success, just not a financial one, I sometimes try to imagine 180k people and my mind breaks a little. Thankfully game dev is not my primary source of income, otherwise I'd have been homeless years ago. I still want to make a game that I can be proud of, and hopefully the next one is the one!

document fetched 2026-11-12 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xthz7p/my_game_was_a_small_hit_but_i_was_stupid