NeurIPS reject -> ICLR: How much reviewer feedback are you actually implementing ? [D]
retained text
Welp, NeurIPS is a wrap for those of us who got rejected 😭 Off we go to ICLR or whatever the next venue is, hopefully after making some meaningful changes to the paper. For people who are resubmitting, I’m curious: **how much of the NeurIPS reviewer feedback are you actually implementing?** Did you try to address basically everything the reviewers brought up, or are you being selective and only making changes where you think the criticism is valid/useful? I’m curious about papers that got questioned on **novelty or significance**. How many of you got comments along those lines, and what exactly were the reviewers questioning? For example: * “The contribution is incremental” * “Not sufficiently different from prior work” * “The empirical gains don’t justify the proposed method” * “The problem itself isn’t significant enough” * “Theoretical contribution is limited” * “Interesting idea, but unclear what the broader impact/significance is” If you’re comfortable sharing, what did the reviewers say, and **how are you changing the paper before resubmitting ?** Specially since deadline is also pretty close, how are you handling the pressure of this very close deadline ? Also curious whether anyone is deliberately *not* implementing certain reviewer suggestions because you think they would take the work in the wrong direction. Would love to hear how others are approaching the post-NeurIPS revision process.
document fetched 2026-09-26 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/1wpognv/neurips_reject_iclr_how_much_reviewer_feedback