What if Valve had chosen a $5,000 Steam Direct fee instead of $100?
retained text
Back in 2017, when Valve replaced Steam Greenlight with Steam Direct, they considered fees ranging from $100 to $5,000 per game. The main idea behind a higher fee was to **discourage spam and low-effort games** by making mass publishing significantly more expensive, encourage developers to take each release more seriously, and reduce the overwhelming number of submissions to Steam. Of course, a higher fee wouldn't necessarily guarantee better games. Looking at how much low effort content, asset flips, and slop gets released on Steam today, I wonder if choosing $5,000 would have made a difference. I'm an indie developer, and for my own project I'm looking at spending around $15,000 on artists alone, several thousand more on audio, not counting my own time as a programmer. It is my passion but also my work, the thing that I do for living, so yes, I put all my effort on it to be succesfull at least for recover the inversion and keep working on more projects. I have a wife and a daughter I want to give everything I can to, so I can't afford to do this just for fun. That's already a massive financial and personal investment. Having to save another $5,000 would definitely hurt, but compared to the overall cost of development, I think it would be manageable. Especially if Valve refunded the fee after reaching a certain revenue threshold, like they do now. I'm not saying having $5,000 makes your game good, or that developers without that money don't deserve to publish. Plenty of talented indies would have been excluded, and that's a serious downside. But I also believe a higher entry fee would have discouraged mass producing low effort games that rely on being extremely cheap to release. Maybe a higher barrier would have meant fewer games, but also a less saturated storefront for everyone who made it through. I'm not convinced $5,000 is necessarily the right number, but I do wonder whether Valve solved one problem by creating another. What do you think? Would a $5,000 fee have significantly reduced Steam slop, or would it mostly have hurt smaller indies while loweffort publishers found ways around it?
document fetched 2026-10-22 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xbuyz4/what_if_valve_had_chosen_a_5000_steam_direct_fee