First homelab build: dedicated GPU workstation vs. cloud compute? Looking for hardware and infrastructure advice
retained text
I'm doing some research involving 2D-to-3D reconstruction and processing. I've been using RunPod for GPU compute, but I'm not particularly happy with the experience. I'm considering moving to my own hardware rather than continuing to rent compute. I'd also prefer not to build this around AWS. This has me thinking about building my first proper homelab. I've been a software engineer for about 15 years, but the last PC I built was almost 10 years ago (I can still game on it!). I'm comfortable with Linux, Docker, development environments, and software infrastructure, but I've never put together a dedicated home server or compute setup. I'm leaning toward owning the hardware. The upfront cost is higher, but being able to run jobs whenever I want, leave things processing overnight, and have my own persistent storage sounds worth it. I also want a machine capable of gaming, especially with GTA VI coming. I'm trying to figure out whether I should build one powerful workstation that does everything, or approach this more like a homelab with separate storage and compute. Here are the builds I've been considering: |Build|GPU|CPU|RAM|Approx. total| |:-|:-|:-|:-|:-| |Used budget|Used RTX 3090 24GB|Ryzen 9 5900X|64GB|$2,804| |My pick|Refurbished RTX 3090 24GB (warranty)|Ryzen 9 5950X|64GB|$3,369| |More memory|Used RTX 3090 24GB|Ryzen 9 5950X|128GB|$3,427| |48GB VRAM|Refurbished Quadro RTX 8000 48GB|Ryzen 9 5900X|64GB|$3,654| |Best on merit|Refurbished RTX 3090 24GB (warranty)|Ryzen 9 5950X|128GB|\~$3,920| |48GB, faster|Used RTX A6000 48GB|Ryzen 9 5950X|128GB|\~$6,400| |New professional GPU|RTX PRO 5000 48GB|Ryzen 9 5950X|128GB|\~$9,300| |New high-end gaming GPU|RTX 5090 32GB|Ryzen 9 9950X|64GB DDR5|\~$8,900| Prices include the other components. The \~$3,920 build includes a 1000W PSU. **What I'd really like advice on:** 1. Would you build one workstation for gaming, development and GPU compute, or separate the homelab/server from the gaming PC? 2. Is there a sensible way to have persistent network storage with compute that can be upgraded independently? 3. For 2D-to-3D processing, would you prioritize 24GB VRAM, 48GB VRAM, or newer GPU performance? 4. Is a used RTX 3090 still a sensible starting point, or am I better off investing in newer hardware? 5. What am I overlooking in terms of cooling, power consumption, storage, networking, and running jobs overnight? I'm not opposed to spending more if there's a good reason. I just don't want to spend $9k when a $4k setup would do the job.
document fetched 2026-11-12 00:38 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/homelab/comments/1xtnntv/first_homelab_build_dedicated_gpu_workstation_vs