← sources

My expected return gauge blends three valuation legs. Right now they disagree by almost 8 points.

source: reddit (reddit:investing)published 2026-11-18 12:26ingested 2026-11-19 02:37

retained text

I track expected 10 year real return as an equal weight blend of three regressions. One uses log CAPE, one uses the Buffett indicator deviation from trend, and one uses earnings yield minus the real 10 year yield. Today the blend reads plus 0.8 percent a year. The legs do not agree at all. CAPE implies minus 0.4 percent a year, the Buffett leg implies minus 2.5 percent, and the earnings yield leg implies plus 5.2 percent. The one standard deviation band runs from minus 3.4 to plus 4.9 percent, so even the optimistic edge sits below the long run real average near plus 6.5 percent. I adopted the blend only after it beat CAPE alone out of sample, cutting forecast error by about a third. The disagreement itself feels like information. Two price based legs say starting price is punishing, while the earnings yield leg says equities still earn enough against real yields. How do you handle it when your valuation inputs point in opposite directions?

document fetched 2026-11-19 00:27 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/investing/comments/1xzdz0z/my_expected_return_gauge_blends_three_valuation