Why I'm not worried about AI game theft (at least not for my own game)
retained text
EDIT: Apparently the post is too long. Sorry? I have a lot to say. There's a TL;DR directly below this edit. You don't have to announce that the post is long in the comments, lol. TL;DR: If your game has an inspired story and inspired atmosphere, or is otherwise truly creative, it will always outshine a game identical in gameplay but made with AI. My game is a game that only I could make. Its story is one only I could write. Just because someone tells their AI to copy my game, flips the assets, and ships it does not mean they've made something that competes with my own game, because the AI game has nothing that makes my game unique or interesting. If you read the above and thought "wow, they must have a unique game idea that nobody else could make" and then checked my profile only to find that my game is, in fact, Plants VS Zombies with the roguelike mechanics of Balatro, you may become doubtful of everything else I said, but I actually think its especially exemplary of my point. My game is not meant to surpass PVZ, but to be a unique spin on the gameplay idea. I never set out to make a PVZ clone, I originally started making it as an experiment to see if PVZ would fit into the roguelike mold. I'm going to talk about the story of the game some, and that story is absent from the few gameplay GIFs and screenshots I've posted on other subreddits, so take it on faith that my game has a story at all. Sorry if this seems like showcasing or sneakily advertising, I just don't want people coming into the comments pointing this stuff out. I would like if discussion in the comments of this post was limited to the points I'm trying to make in this post and not about my own game. Also, I'm going to be alienating AI users incredibly hard in this post. Yes, I AM biased. The harsh things I say about AI and AI-Generated assets in this post are only my opinion, except for the ones which are just facts. Once again, I would like for discussion in the comments to be about the points I make in this post and not full of people defending themselves for using AI. Please do that somewhere else. This and other gamedev subreddits seem to neglect stories in games during discussions of them, but they are arguably one of IF NOT THE most important aspects of video games as a whole. So many of my favorite games have rich, powerful stories that could not have been told through any other medium than video games. Think Undertale, Deltarune, Omori, In Stars and Time, all those "indie-darling RPGs" that gain a huge fandom despite their middling actual gameplay because of the love and passion put into the world and characters. I'm naturally predisposed to writing these sorts of stories just because those are my favorite kinds, so even though my own game could have gotten away with having an "excuse to play the game" like a Super Mario Bros. game, I ended up writing one anyway. With that out of the way, let's talk about something I call "inspired choices." An inspired choice, as I'm going to be using it, is a design decision that's unique to the person who made it. Their own preferences and the way their brain works leads them to make this decision, and very few other people would have thought to make it. Let's take a game called "Buckshot Roulette" as an example. Buckshot Roulette is a game where you play Russian Roulette with a shotgun against one other person (the "dealer"), and it's kind of a roguelike. Before every load of the shotgun you get a number of items that have effects like letting you see whether the next chambered bullet is a live or a blank, preventing your opponent from using their next turn, a bunch of other stuff. Anyone could make a Russian Roulette Roguelike, but it was an inspired choice to make the setting the back of a shady nightclub, the "dealer" a freaky creature who's only a head and hands and is submerged in darkness for most of the game, the items cigarettes, beer cans, and handcuffs among other similar implements, give the game a gritty, low poly aesthetic with an aggressive pixel filter, I could go on. Anybody could make a Russian Roulette Roguelike, but only the creator of Buckshot Roulette could make Buckshot Roulette. A youtuber by the name of Jimmy McGee (who makes incredible videos might I add) once said something along the lines of "An authorial voice is not felt in a single design decision, but by the combination of several design decisions that work together to create a specific tone" while talking about Earthbound (and he was talking about AI there, too!). I like this quote a lot. Now that we've discussed why games made by humans can be so inspired and creative, lets discuss why AI made games can't. AI is NOT creative. You've heard armchair programmers explain what a neural network is and how they work a thousand times before (and if you haven't you can look it up), so I won't bother. The only thing relevant to this conversation is that all that an AI does, all it can ever do, is blend up its input data and turn it into output data. If an image generating AI has only ever seen the Mona Lisa, it will only ever produce the Mona Lisa. If it has only seen paintings in the form of Etsy store mockups, you can be damn sure whatever paintings it produces will look like an Etsy store mockup. My point is, an AI will never make an inspired choice like a human will. Its output will always be the average of all of its billions of images or books worth of training data. Not only that, the "authorial voice" of an AI is all over the place. AI games already have a problem with their aesthetics being all over the place, or at least looking like the creator is exclusively using assets they found on itch.io. If you get an AI to make a game with the same "pitch" as a different game, it'll be significantly worse. We can take my game again. I made a PVZ roguelike, and I chose to make the defending units Demons and the attacking units Angels because I like divine creatures a whole bunch, which also led me to be able to say, through story and gameplay, a bunch of stuff about Hell, God, and Religion. My decision, in terms of story, to give a strangely emotional story to a PVZ style game is one that only I would make, and it's only because, as said before, those are the kinds of stories I like to see in games. The artstyle and music are consistent, the tone and atmosphere are considered, so it looks and feels like a game someone might actually play, at least in my opinion. An AI would not do ANY of these things! Guided by a human who's making these kinds of decisions, maybe, but the inspiration and creativity would most likely not be able to shine through the sloppy AI generated assets. The amount of creativity you can show in your game is inversely proportional to how much AI you use in it. Letting an AI do \*everything\* means the game is uncreative, and doing most of the work yourself means you might as well have not used AI at all. There's a big reason why AAA studios are, to this day, still only giving AI a very small role in developing their games if at all. They care first and foremost about turning a profit, but something I've been kind of trying to get at through this post is that the AI "all over the place" aesthetic, which has a noisy and weak authorial voice, is not something people want to see in their games. They want unique experiences, and they want to see you put yourself into your game. AI cannot provide this. The game made over the course of 2 years by someone with genuinely inspired ideas and with passion and heart will always outshine the game made in 2 weeks by someone primarily using AI. This will be true forever, or at least until AI becomes actually sentient and can make truly inspired decisions. One more thing. Have you noticed that those games I mentioned before, Undertale/Deltarune, Omori, In Stars and Time, don't have AI copies of them yet despite being wildly popular? Think about why that is. Obviously, they all came out before you could do the AI copying thing, but there's more to them than that. You \*can't\* copy them with AI. The point of those games isn't gameplay, it's the powerful story, rich characters, the dialog, the flavor, the heart. AI can't write a powerful story, rich characters, good dialog, it can only write the average of every story, every character, every line of dialog. An AI would miss the point of Undertale. If Undertale came out in 2026, an AI copy of it would never sell, but more importantly an AI copy of Undertale could never be made. Those are my thoughts, anyway. I'd like to hear yours. Maybe I'm uninformed, maybe AI has grown a soul and has figured out how to make an Undertale. What do you think?
document fetched 2026-10-30 00:26 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/gamedev/comments/1xip4sk/why_im_not_worried_about_ai_game_theft_at_least