Why I’m Bullish on MELI.
retained text
**TL;DR:** MELI is like a coiled spring, absorbing an upfront accounting burden under US GAAP (CECL) to scale a massive fintech ecosystem while simultaneously cementing an unmatched logistics and payments network in Latin America. Its rapidly expanding credit portfolio creates a timing mismatch between the upfront recognition of expected credit losses and the subsequent generation of interest income. Yet, the underlying lending business maintains an attractive NIMAL (approximately 20%), already net of credit provisions and funding costs. As portfolio growth eventually normalizes, the incremental provisioning load should become less pronounced relative to the accumulated earning asset base. Combined with operating leverage across its commerce, payments and logistics infrastructure, this creates the potential for substantial profit growth \_\_\_ If you look at MELI's consolidated numbers recently, operating margins have compressed from historical levels of 9.8% in Q3'25 to 6.3% in Q3'26. To a casual observer browsing financial screens, it looks like a collapse driven by margin erosion or fierce competition. However, digging into the P&L and supplementary portfolio disclosures reveals a more nuanced picture. A significant portion of this compression is associated with the extraordinary expansion of its fintech business (Mercado Pago / Mercado Credito), the timing of expected credit loss recognition under US GAAP (CECL), alongside macroeconomic pressures on COGS. Here is why I am fundamentally bullish on MELI: **1. The fintech provisioning dynamics and NIMAL** Under US GAAP (CECL), a lending business experiencing parabolic growth faces a particular accounting dynamic: expected lifetime credit losses are recognized upfront when loans are originated, rather than only when defaults actually materialize. This creates a timing mismatch between the recognition of expected credit losses and the subsequent generation of interest income throughout the life of the loan. What makes MELI particularly interesting is its underlying lending unit economics. * Its consolidated NIMAL reached 20.1% in Q3'26. And NIMAL is already calculated after provisions for doubtful accounts and third-party funding costs, so this is not a gross lending spread: it reflects the portfolio's net interest economics. * When the portfolio grows at 60%+ YoY, MELI must continuously recognize expected lifetime credit losses on newly originated loans. Consequently, the incremental provisioning expense associated with these new cohorts can significantly weigh on consolidated operating earnings, even while the existing loan portfolio maintains attractive unit economics. **The key point:** Credit portfolio growth cannot remain at 60%+ indefinitely due to the law of large numbers. As portfolio growth normalizes, the incremental provisioning burden should become less pronounced relative to the accumulated earning asset base. Assuming credit quality remains stable and NIMAL holds at attractive levels, the accumulated portfolio should increasingly contribute to operating earnings and profit. **2. Short credit duration mitigates LatAm credit risk** Critics often argue that consumer credit in Latin America carries high default risks. While regional risk is naturally higher compared to developed markets, MELI's model has a built-in defense mechanism: a very short portfolio duration, averaging approximately 3.7 months for consumer loans, 2.7 months for credit cards, and 3.2 months for merchant credit. Unlike traditional banks holding long-term consumer debt, MELI's credit book turns over multiple times a year. If macroeconomic conditions deteriorate, the company can adjust scoring algorithms, tighten credit lines, or reprice yields relatively quickly. High spreads combined with fast portfolio recycling provide flexibility to adapt credit underwriting. Management appears confident in the resilience of this model, and I agree. **3. Asian cross-border competitors face structural headwinds** Wall Street often attributes margin pressure to competition from Asian cross-border platforms such as Shopee, Temu and AliExpress. This overlooks the structural advantages MELI has in Latin America: * Delivery speed & average ticket: Temu and Shopee compete heavily on ultra-low-ticket items, often with longer delivery times (1 or 2+ weeks). MELI dominates everyday consumer needs through its proprietary fulfillment and air fleet network, offering same-day or next-day delivery in many markets. It is also promoting Meli+ as a loyalty ecosystem comparable to Amazon Prime. * Fiscal import restrictions: Governments across Latin America, including Brazil, Mexico and Chile, are increasingly closing tax loopholes on low-value cross-border imports to protect domestic tax revenues and ‘level’ the playing field for local businesses. This makes subsidized cross-border shipping increasingly challenging, whereas MELI's local logistics network benefits from economies of scale as package volumes increase (GMV and items sold are also growing at 30%+ YoY). **4. The convenience walled garden: zero-friction lock-in** Unlike pure neobanks such as Nubank, which operate without a proprietary marketplace or physical fulfillment network, MELI has built an integrated ecosystem driven by convenience and cross-selling. * Yield on idle cash: Users keep money in Mercado Pago because it earns interest automatically (matching local benchmark rates) without locking liquidity. * One-click velocity: Users can purchase on MELI's marketplace using their Mercado Pago balance with virtually zero friction, no external redirects or repeated payment authentication. Neobanks simply cannot offer this level of frictionless, integrated commerce and financial ecosystem. What are your thoughts on MELI?
document fetched 2026-11-12 00:46 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/ValueInvesting/comments/1xtuu3c/why_im_bullish_on_meli