← sources

Solo admin (16 sites): Does ditching half-baked Cisco Umbrella for Cloudflare or a lightweight alternative make sense?

source: reddit (reddit:sysadmin)published 2026-10-23 14:35ingested 2026-10-24 02:39

retained text

Need a quick sanity check from folks who run lean environments.

Our org is burning cash right now on a bunch of acquisitions and building an actual stadium, so management is pushing hard to cut costs across the board. I took over this environment about a year ago after the previous IT team was wiped out, and I've spent the last 12 months untangling everything they left behind.

One big line item coming up for renewal is Cisco Umbrella/Secure Access, and I’m seriously considering killing it.

The reality on the ground:

* The old team never actually finished the deployment. It's basically just running on the out-of-the-box default policy everywhere.
* Over the last month, it literally blocked maybe 20 destinations org-wide.
* Cisco is pushing the whole expensive Secure Connect ecosystem, and the renewal quote is brutal for a tool that’s barely doing anything for us right now.
* I am the *only* admin handling 16 physical sites plus this stadium build. I don't have the bandwidth to build out policies or babysit an over-engineered stack. Simplicity has to win right now.

My thought process is: why not just drop the contract and move to something lighter?  
  
I could point our firewalls to Cloudflare (1.1.1.2 / Quad9), set up Cloudflare Zero Trust/Gateway (which is basically free or pennies compared to Cisco), or even look at self-hosting something like AdGuard Home or Pi-hole.   
  
Honestly, basic upstream filtering feels like it would catch more junk than our current Umbrella setup without the massive price tag.

Thoughts? 

document fetched 2026-10-24 10:38 · canonical https://reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/1xdfs9l/solo_admin_16_sites_does_ditching_halfbaked_cisco